Search Results
Search Results
-
Case law commentary about the admissibility on the “adherence of the appeal” in the procedure before the local court judge. Admissibility of complaint appeal against an appellate court judgment
Two contradictory judgments of the Supreme Court on the admissibility of adhesion to an appeal in a procedure before the Local Court Judge (Juzgado de Policial Local) regulated by Law No. 18,287 are critically analyzed.
Likewise, the admissibility of a complaint appeal is analyzed with respect to the resolution of a Court of Appeals that declares an appeal inadmissible.
-
SETTLEMENT OF THE JUDGMENT GIVEN IN A CLASS PROCEDURE AND ALTERNATIVES FOR THE REPAIR OF INDETERMINATE CONSUMERS
This paper analyzes the rule pronounced by the Court of Appeals of Santiago on September 7, 2023, in case No. 5740-2021, titled “Servicio Nacional del Consumidor con Farmacias Cruz Verde y otras”, referring to the payment of damages suffered by consumers in the “Farmacias Case”, which condemned Farmacias Cruz Verde, Salcobrand and Fasa for collusion and which resulted in a collective proceeding ordering the payment of the corresponding indemnities to consumers. This proceeding ended with an agreement between SERNAC and Farmacias Cruz Verde and Salcobrand, excluding Fasa, which decided to continue with the proceeding by means of an appeal.
-
THE COURT’S DETACHMENT AS A LIMIT TO THE EXERCISE OF JUDICIAL POWER
In the present paper, the judgment issued by the Supreme Court on April 30, 2026, in case docket No. 1608-2023, is analyzed with respect to the scope of the court’s loss of jurisdiction and its consequences for the functional competence of the Court of Appeals when hearing an appeal.
-
Admissibility and weighing of the evidence in the appeal courts and the duty to substantiate the sentence
In the present work, the sentence pronounced by the Supreme Court, is analyzed, referring to the need to consider the evidence rendered in the second ins- tance for an adequate justification of the sentence.
-
Property quality and consumer safety
The present commentary analyses the case Servicio Nacional del Consumidor con Inmobiliaria Francisco de Aguirre Limitada, in particular the judgments of the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court on the occasion of the hearing of an appeal and, later, cassation on the merits; which dealt with the scope of application of Law No. 19,496 on the Protection of Consumer Rights. To this end, and after briefly summarizing the facts, we will explain the legal problem posed by the concepts of quality and safety and their relationship with the applicable regulations. In turn, we will present the arguments of the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court in this regard, with special consideration of the dissenting vote of the Member Attorney Ms. Chaimovich on distinguishing the rights of safety from the quality of housing within the consumer relationship. With this, we intend to achieve an adequate understanding of the matters excluded from the law and the distinction between the rights it protects.