Top
RCHDP

Search Results

65 Results
Showing 1-6 matching the phrase case law.

Search Results

  • THE LOSS OF CHANCE DOCTRINE IN THE COMPARATIVE LAW HORIZON

    Hugo Alejandro Cardenas Villarreal

    The legal theory of loss of opportunity generates genuine fascination. While it has been accepted by several jurisdictions in recent years, it is still being debated in others that had previously accepted it. However, this notion’s popularity contrasts with the lack of clarity regarding its scope of application and legal regime, which has led to somewhat uncontrolled case law. Against this back drop, the present paper seeks to offer a comparative analysis of how the loss of opportunity theory is perceived and implemented in some of the most significant jurisdictions within the common law and civil law traditions. Despite the disparity of approaches observed in the comparative landscape, this paper identifies the rules on which there seems to be agreement, as well as the alternative solution that has been adopted by jurisdictions that have rejected the theory.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • EXCEPTION CLAUSES IN ARGENTINE PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW, WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO HISTORICAL AND COMPARATIVE ASPECTS

    Milton César Feuillade

    This paper examines the exception clauses in Argentine Private International Law, which were given legislative form in the Civil and Commercial Code in 2015. It identifies the comparative sources on which they draw and traces their origins, since our working hypothesis concerns their current operation and projected use by legal practitioners. Methodologically, the study relies on comparative case law, in light of the scarcity of domestic decisions. The article provides a structured analysis of the proximity principle and the exception clause, addressing their relationship, content, and scope, and proposes a typology. Building on their characteristics, comparative assessment, and the relevant scholarship, it advances proposals for their application. Among statutory models, Swiss law serves as a primary reference, and, in our view, the Belgian Code offers the most precise and modern formulation. The clause’s exceptional character is linked to outcomes that would otherwise be manifestly arbitrary or unsuitable for the case; it should be invoked only when necessary.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • Liability to injury to human rights: need for express constitucional recognition? a review from the perspective of damage repair in the tort law

    Pamela Prado López

    In the midst of the debate regarding the new Chilean Constitution, this paper goes through the consequences of an eventual incorporation of a norm of constitutional rank in our law that, to a greater or lesser extent, establishes the duty of reparation in the event of a violation of human rights, similar to other Latin American Constitutions; in particular we will analyze the topic of damage repair. The reason behind looking through the different modes that damage repairing for human rights violation takes, is to demonstrate that the law of liability and the standards of human rights law can complement each other, especially in the case that the state or its agents are the culprits of those violations.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • SUSTAINABLE CONTRACTUAL CLAUSES AS A WAY FOR SMALL AND MEDIUM-SIZED ENTERPRISES TO BECOME A DRIVING FORCE FOR SUSTAINABILITY IN GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

    Lorena Carvajal Arenas

    In the modern world, contracts favour social purposes by providing a good setting for the regulation of sustainability. Within this framework, this article points out the inequality in bargaining power between lead companies and their suppliers that has hitherto not been extensively explored in the literature. This is emphasised by transnational laws, whose focus is on the role of buyers for the implementation of sustainability in global supply chains. Thus, suppliers, usually small and medium-sized enterprises, are mere rule followers, which could make them vulnerable. It is postulated here that is possible to overcome this by bottom-up activities – that is, the negotiation of sustainable contractual clauses including the input of small and medium-sized enterprises, and compromises by the parent company in capacity-building for them. This implies a repurposing of the contract, bringing small and medium-sized enterprises to the centre and making them aware of their power and co-responsible for the spread of sustainability. Buyers should be amenable to this change since it would allow production according to their values, opening their reach to potential new markets and also complying with law, which is more stringent every day in terms of sustainability. This rationale is complemented in the article by examination of a real case and a consideration of the anatomy of a sustainable contractual clause according to these suggestions.


    PDF
  • A CONCEPTUAL APPROACH BETWEEN THE DAMAGE AND ITS IMPORTANCE IN THE DIES A QUO OF THE STATUTE OF LIMITATION IN THE TORTS DAMAGE ACTION. A NECESSARY PROPOSAL REGARDING OF ARTICLE 2235 OF THE ECUADORIAN CIVIL CODE

    Leonardo Coronel Larrea

    In Ecuadorian Law, article 2235 of the Civil Code offers an answer regarding the accounting for the statute of limitations in the action for torts. However, the rule generates a discussion when certain cases are not covered or protected by the classical interpretation. The foundational interpretative rule understands that the calculation of the prescription must be from the verification of the wrongful act, understanding that the act has been perpetrated there. Nevertheless, this provision does not contemplate all types of damage, specifically hidden damage, and continued damage. This generates a conflict between the rule of the Torts Law that all damages must be compensated against the security in the legal relationships that the Statute of limitation seeks. Therefore, it is necessary to delimit the concept of compensable damage to understand and know how these types of damages have been conceived according to their consummation in time from an Ecuadorian conception. Accordingly, it will be possible to analyze the statute of limitation and how it has acted in case law and comparative law. In which, there is already a solution that determines the beginning of the statute of limitation in each case of hidden damage and continuing damage. In this way, a current solution will be proposed for the calculation of the statute of limitation in Ecuador.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • ABOUT THE SANCTION FOR UNFAIR TERMS IN CONSUMER LAW

    Maria Elisa Morales, Diego Nichi Burgos

    This article examines the sanction applicable to unfair terms in Chilean consumer law, in light of a recent decision of the Supreme Court (Case No. 34713-2023), which classified as unfair an acceleration clause contained in a mortgage loan agreement. The judgment is of particular interest as it expressly resolves the doctrinal debate concerning the nature of the invalidity provided for in Article 16 of Law No. 19,496, holding that it amounts to absolute nullity. The article sets out the facts of the case, systematises the main doctrinal positions on the sanction for unfairness, and reviews the evolution of case law on the matter. Finally, the authors argue that the solution adopted by the Supreme Court is only partially correct, although it is commendable insofar as it is grounded in existing law: it recognises the public policy character of the control of unfair terms and allows for a coherent integration of the Con­sumer Protection Act with the general regime of nullity, without resorting to de lege ferenda constructions. 

    PDF (Español (España))
Advanced filters
Published After
Published Before