Top
RCHDP

Search Results

3 Results
Showing 1-3 matching the phrase discrecionalidad.

Search Results

  • LEGAL PROVISIONS ON INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS: RULES OR MERE ADVICE?

    Rodrigo Coloma Correa, Cristián Banfi del Río, Claudio Agüero San Juan

    This article addresses an old debate concerning the pragmatic dimension of legal provisions on contractual interpretation. The article uses a case decided in a dissenting manner by the lower courts and the Supreme Court as a common thread. It follows from our analysis that those provisions would not be rules (in a strong sense of bindingness), nor mere advice (in a sense of permissions), but they belong to the category of interpretation standards, that do not impose a result but a burden of justification, whether they are used or not. This form of understanding explains, prima facie, the Supreme Court’s power to modify decisions in cassation on the merits, and urges to deepen on what we understand by breach of law and error.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • THE PRINCIPLE OF PROPORTIONALITY IN PRIVATE LAW: A GENERAL APPROACH AND A PARTICULARIZATION FROM A CONSUMER PROTECTION PERSPECTIVE

    Juan Luis Goldenberg Serrano

    The principle of proportionality, rooted in ideals of balance and reasonableness, is challenged at the legal level given its equivocal formulation. In public law, it is generally referred to as limiting the State’s discretion and protecting the rights of individuals through a threefold examination of adequacy, necessity, and proportionality in a strict sense. Such an analysis cannot be simply transferred to private law, either because it could end up eroding the logic of private autonomy, or because relations between private individuals cannot be qualified by the extent to which public policies affect fundamental rights. On the contrary, an evaluative weighing of the rights assigned to each party must be carried out, whether this exercise is done ex ante by the legislator, or ex post by the court. Hence, it is proposed that, unless there is an express or implicit redirection to the constitutional meaning of the principle, the balance between the rights of individuals must be observed in the light of criteria that are proper to private law, such as accepted good behavior (boni mores) and good faith. For these purposes, it is also postulated that in consumer law only a particularization of these rules can be observed, but this does not detract from the fact that their basis can be observed in other private law relationships, where there is a weakness of one of the parties, so that the principle of proportionality, based on ideas from the private law sphere, also serves as a corrective element.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • NOTARIAL INSTRUCTIONS AND THE ROLE OF THE NOTARY PUBLIC IN THE PAYMENT OF THE PRICE AT THE SALE

    Javier Rodríguez

    A recent decision of the Supreme Court offers valuable guidelines regarding the way in which a notary public must comply with the instructions given by the parties at a sale to pay the price. The decision highlights the lack of leeway of the notary public in order to determine the scope of the instructions, as well as his or her inability to interfere in the risk allocation agreed by the parties. The Supreme Court also deepens in the legal nature of the instructions and applies to them the rules of the contract of mandate. The commentary critically reviews these subjects in view of the practical scope which the instructions fulfil.

    PDF (Español (España))
Advanced filters
Published After
Published Before