Search Results
Search Results
-
CRITERIA FOR THE ASSESSMENT OF MORAL DAMAGES: A VIEW FROM CHILEAN CASE LAW
This article provides a critical assessment of the criteria employed by Chilean courts to justify the amount awarded for moral damages. Based on an analysis of a series of judgments recognizing such damages, the decisions are classified according to the central argument relied upon by the court in determining the quantum of compensation. Although this classification may be debatable in some cases, given that the decisive reasoning is not always explicit, the selection process is made transparent through cross-references provided in the footnotes. The initial classification criteria were drawn from legal scholarship and subsequently supplemented with additional criteria identified during the jurisprudential review. This study makes it possible to distinguish between argumentative practices that are consistent with the rules and principles of civil liability and those that deviate from them, thereby contributing to a clearer understanding of which criteria are legally sound and which are deficient.