Search Results
Search Results
-
¿QUÉ SE HA DICHO SOBRE EL FUNCIONAMIENTO DE LA JUSTICIA CIVIL EN CHILE? APORTES PARA LA REFORMA
In recent years, there is a growing consensus on the necessity of a civil justice reform. This consensus has crystallized into various proposals that until today are under legislative discussion. Notwithstanding, a deeper analysis on the functioning of the civil justice in the country, particularly the precise identification of its problems, is an urgent need to meet if we expect for a success of the public policy in this area. For these purposes, this article aims to account for the main critics that exist in the literature on the subject and systematize them according to four categories: existing barriers for accessing to civil justice, procedural design and the excessive written character of the civil procedure, lack of heterogeneity of civil filings, and the length of these cases. Finally, future research areas are identified to serve the necessity of the minimum diagnosis required to strengthen the discussion on civil justice reform in Chile.
-
LEGAL EVIDENCE AND THE SEARCH OF TRUTH: IS IT POSSIBLE TO INTERPRET THE PROBATORY RULES OF THE CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE ACCORDING TO A PRO VERITATIS PRINCIPLE?
This paper addresses the existing tension between the system of legal or weighted evidence currently in force in the Chilean Civil Procedure Code and the pursuit of truth as the primary goal of the probatory stage. In the absence of a civil procedure reform capable of closing the gap between traditional normative structures and contemporary epistemic demands, it proposes an interpretation of probatory rules in accordance with the proposed pro veritatis principle. Through a historical, dogmatic and normative analysis, it is sustained that many of these rules maintain, to varying degrees, an epistemic orientation that justifies their reinterpretation. In that sense, a re-reading of such rules is proposed, aimed at mitigating their most restrictive effects while strengthening the justice of the verdict based on a reasonably proven factic truth. -
BURDEN OF PROOF DEFEASIBILITY IN CONTRACTS LIABILITY: TOWARDS EVIDENCE EASINESS IN CHILE
This paper analyzes from the perspective of the legal reasoning theory the article 1698 of the Chilean Civil Code that contains the general rule on the distribution of the burden of proof. From Frederick Schauer’s conceptual framework –that understands the prescriptive rules as generalization with background justifications– I propose to demonstrate that the 1698’ distribution of burdens can be defeated. Here will be shown that there is case-law in which the 1698’ generalizations have no use for its background justification and, accordingly, the judges defeat its application. The impeditive and modification facts, in one hand, and the evidence easiness, in the other, are the main hypothesis of defeasibility on the burden distribution made by the article 1698 of the Civil Code.