Search Results
Search Results
-
DE LA RESPONSABILIDAD CIVIL COMO INSTRUMENTO DE PROTECCIÓN AMBIENTAL
Este trabajo examina la responsabilidad civil como mecanismo de control ambiental (esto es, para la prevención y la reparación del daño ambiental per se) en el Derecho Comunitario europeo y chileno. Se basa en la doctrina anglosajona y nacional y en sus respectivos ordenamientos legales. Intenta comparar los fundamentos y los fines generales de las responsabilidades por culpa y estricta. Luego, confronta la responsabilidad civil con el Derecho Administrativo (regulación) en cuanto hace a la protección ambiental. Concluye con una reflexión sobre las perspectivas de la responsabilidad civil –con sus notas características– como medio más o menos eficiente pa-ra acometer el daño al entorno ecológico.
-
THE PROOF OF SPECIFIC CAUSATION: AN INSURMOUNTABLE BARRIER TO IMPOSE ENVIRONMENTAL LIABILITY AND TORT LIABILITY FOR HARMS ARISING FROM CLIMATE CHANGE?
In this article I argue that, in order to overcome successfully the current impossibility of showing the causal link between greenhouse gas emissions released by one or more individualized agents and the environmental and/or personal damage for which reparation is sought –immediately attributable to specific climate changes and more remotely to global warming where their activity has an impact– it is not enough for the Chilean environmental courts and courts of justice to use judicial presumptions and shift the burden of proof to those actors, but they would have to modify radically their understanding of the foundation and aim of environmental liability and tort law, through the replacement of the traditional and deterministic idea of causation, based on but for test, by a probabilistic notion of it, supported by the climate attribution science and normative criteria of causation, whereby the emitters are held liable for harm that most likely did not inflict but at most contributed to cause.
-
JURISDICTION AND APPLICABLE LAW ON LIABILITY FOR CROSS-BORDER ENVIRONMENTAL DAMAGE: THE EUROPEAN UNION’S SYSTEM
The rules of private international law in the European context have evolved considerably since 1970. Such rules applied to trans-boundary pollution problems pose greater environmental and people protection because of the possibility to make use of favor laesi principle, which allows choosing the forum and applicable law of the place where damage originated or where damage occurred. however, Directive 2004/35/EC, which regulates the environmental or per se ecological damages, contains no enough rules of private international law producing a number of problems with the Regulations that discipline the competence and the law applicable to extracontractual civil liability cases (respectively, Brussels i and Romeii). This paper aims to identify and expose all these rules in an orderly manner to demonstrate the conflicts warned by the doctrine.