Search Results
Search Results
-
LINKAGE BETWEEN THE INJURED PARTY AND THE INSURER, BASIS AND REGIME: A PRIVATE LAW ISSUE
With Insurance Law reform, came the discussion about incorporation of direct action against insurer in non-compulsory liability insurance in Chile. The points of view were polarized in positions for and against, but a great part of the debate run from a distributive justice perspective. This work seeks to demonstrate that the reasons for linking the third party injured to the insurer, are reasons that respond to Private Law, that is to say, corrective justice reasons. The former gives parameters for the analysis of mechanisms that modify the privity of liability insurance contract. Likewise, it allows to understand more precisely which is the dogmatic meaning of the third party injured’s action to collect which, in the end, was incorporated in the national legislation, as it locates it as an option between two possible extremes (absolute privity or direct action). The understanding of the collect action recognized in national legislation in the context of other options, facilitates the labor of constructing its legal regime and, in particular, the exceptions system.
-
THE PRINCIPLE OF CONTRACTUAL BALANCE IN THE CHILEAN CIVIL CODE AND ITS PARTICULAR IMPORTANCE AS A FOUNDATION SOME INSTITUTIONS OF MODERN LAW OF OBLIGATIONS IN NATIONAL DOGMATIC
The present work aims to address the equilibrium of benefits contained in a contract as a manifestation of the commutative justice imperative, which projects at different moments during the contractual procedure, proposing its dogmatic construction from various legal precepts contained in the Civil Code, and demonstrate how its formulation allows justify the application of certain institutions introduced by the modern law of obligations and contracts, thus contributing to strengthen that dogmatic tendency which, in recent years, has aroused the interest of a prominent sector of the national doctrine.
-
THREE READINGS OF PROCEDURAL GOOD FAITH
Good faith is a key part in the justice. This paper outlines three conceptually different ways to understand the procedural good faith in modern litigation: a strong thesis (to contribute to the justice of the case), a minimal thesis (not to litigate with malice) and a more than minimal thesis (to fulfill with certain duties of collaboration and procedural burdens). Each approach entails dissimilar implications for the parties, third parties and the court itself. This analysis demonstrates that good faith understood as a more than minimal threshold is the one that is best suited to a process where private and public interests must be balanced. To establish the best distribution of the burdens and duties in the litigation is a priority (but not exclusive) task in the procedural literature.
-
ONCE AGAIN, THE DAMAGE: CRITERIA FOR DETERMINING DAMAGE IN CHILE AND THEIR UNDERSTANDING IN JURISPRUDENCE
It is undisputed that harm is the essential element of tort law. Based on this premise, this paper is built showing that the legislature has opted to not define what is harm, while the Chilean literature has not problematized this concept, preferring to build characteristics, or distinguish between different sorts of harms, and then ways to quantify the harm in a pecuniary manner.
But from the philosophy of law and the function of corrective justice, it is necessary to show this paradox that is the main element of tort law is infra problematized to fill it with content, using comparativist and non-comparativist theories, which have been examined in foreign literature to problematize the need of an unique concept of harm nowadays. The goal is to show that litigators and judges will have better tools to confront the harm, specially to address the requirement of motivation that any ruling needs.
-
Three issues of Law Nº 19,496 in a single case: the applicability to micro and small companies; the independence of infringement action from the compensation action and the expiration period of the legal warranty
This paper aims to exhibit three issues that have risen in Consumer Law as a result of the enforcement of Law Nº. 19,496 by our Courts of Justice. First, the enforcement of the protective statute by micro and small companies against their suppliers under the terms of Law No. 20,416. Second, the close dependency or autonomy between infringement liability and compensation, particularly under the hypotheses by which legal warranty operates. Lastly, the expiration period that characterizes the legal warranty as opposed to the general statute of limitations periods set forth in Article 26 of Law No. 19,496.
-
Exclusion of the right of withdrawal in online contracts with consumers in case of goods unsealed after delivery, not suitable to be returned for reasons of protection of health or hygiene
The right to withdraw from the contract is especially relevant today in the contracting of goods and services between businessmen and consumers, particularly in online contracting. In the Spanish legal system, such right is recognized in Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007, of November 16, which approves the consolidated text of the General Law for the Defense of Consumers and Users and other complementary laws. However, among the exclusions to the exercise of this right, the case of the supply of sealed goods not suitable to be returned for reasons of health protection or hygiene and that have been unsealed after delivery is contemplated. In the present work the elements of such exclusion are analyzed, the ineptitude of the good to be returned, characteristics of the “seal”, as well as information that must be provided to the consumer for the exclusion to operate, based on the sentence of the Court of Justice of the European Union, of March 27, 2019, case C 681/17, which admits the exercise by a consumer of the right of withdrawal in case of online purchase of a mattress that is unsealed for testing.