Search Results
Search Results
-
BETWEEN COMPENSATION AND DISTRIBUTION: TORT LAW AS A MECHANISM FOR THE DISTRIBUTION OF MISFORTUNES
The present work is structured under two hypotheses. The first hypothesis claims that corrective justice is the principle that better explains the theory and practice of tort law. The second hypothesis, which shall be called the inseparability thesis, holds it is impossible to separate tort law from the demands of corrective and distributive justice. Both statements are based on its discussion in the Anglo-American literature, although some Chilean will also be discussed. Additionally, it is argued that the two hypotheses are applicable to the practical development of tort law’s problems, providing a theoretical framework that allows creating new solutions to these problems that have not been addressed adequately by Chilean legal scholars.
-
CLASS ACTION BY CREDITORS IN THE FACE OF THE COSTS OF EXTERNALITY AND OBSTRUCTION
This article seeks to relate two topics that are relevant to understanding the procedural alternatives that arise when we face class action by creditors, meaning when various creditors pursuing payment of debts from the estate of a common debtor are faced. In this regard, the legislation considers various means to initiate this class action. However, in the aforementioned context, two categories of costs arise which affect the obtaining of an efficient result, understanding as such the scenario that minimalizes the costs that creditors, the debtor and the justice system assume in order to achieve suitable allocation of the debtor’s resources. I refer to the costs of externality and obstruction. Both the manner in which these costs appear in Chilean legislation and certain proposed solutions shall be the primary matter of analysis in the present work.
-
THE INFLUENCE OF TORT LAW ON STATE LIABILITY FOR LACK OF SERVICE
This article analyzes the influence of tort law on State liability for lack of service from Peter Cane’s theory developed in Tort Law and Public Functions. At this point, the paper addresses three fundamental aspects: the normative structure in the relationships of juridical inequality, the role of egalitarianism in State responsibility, and the duty to compensate the damages caused by public agents. First, it states that the normative structure of public responsibility must be understood in terms of corrective justice since there is a party that must correct the illegitimate damage caused by another. Second, it proposes that equality between the parties functions as a distributive criterion to reduce the state subordination exercised on the administered. Finally, it contrasts the objectives of State responsibility and tort law and identifies the general reasons why the Administration should compensate for the damages caused to the administered.