Search Results
Search Results
-
About the arbitrability of the consumer conflict in Chile: basic supply for a structural replanting
This work addresses the arbitrability of the consumer conflict in chilean law, as a starting point for the rethinking of the entire arbitration system on consumer issues in Chile. It deals with arbitrability in its subjective and material manifestations, and reviews the effects generated in this area by the inalienability of consumer rights, the imperative nature of the norms of Law No 19.496, about protection of consumer rights, and the scope of art. 230 of the Organic Code of Courts, about prohibited arbitration.
-
Three issues of Law Nº 19,496 in a single case: the applicability to micro and small companies; the independence of infringement action from the compensation action and the expiration period of the legal warranty
This paper aims to exhibit three issues that have risen in Consumer Law as a result of the enforcement of Law Nº. 19,496 by our Courts of Justice. First, the enforcement of the protective statute by micro and small companies against their suppliers under the terms of Law No. 20,416. Second, the close dependency or autonomy between infringement liability and compensation, particularly under the hypotheses by which legal warranty operates. Lastly, the expiration period that characterizes the legal warranty as opposed to the general statute of limitations periods set forth in Article 26 of Law No. 19,496.
-
ABOUT THE SANCTION FOR UNFAIR TERMS IN CONSUMER LAW
This article examines the sanction applicable to unfair terms in Chilean consumer law, in light of a recent decision of the Supreme Court (Case No. 34713-2023), which classified as unfair an acceleration clause contained in a mortgage loan agreement. The judgment is of particular interest as it expressly resolves the doctrinal debate concerning the nature of the invalidity provided for in Article 16 of Law No. 19,496, holding that it amounts to absolute nullity. The article sets out the facts of the case, systematises the main doctrinal positions on the sanction for unfairness, and reviews the evolution of case law on the matter. Finally, the authors argue that the solution adopted by the Supreme Court is only partially correct, although it is commendable insofar as it is grounded in existing law: it recognises the public policy character of the control of unfair terms and allows for a coherent integration of the Consumer Protection Act with the general regime of nullity, without resorting to de lege ferenda constructions.
-
The misleading advertising: a problem of provider excusability or consumer recognoscibility?
The purpose of this work is to address what some of the judgments of our courts have come to call erroneous advertising in order to determinate whether, in fact, we are facing a new advertising category or, on the contrary, it constitutes the negative face of advertising misleading. The method used has been to review the judgments of the Santiago Courts of Appeal that have alluded to it between the years 2015 to 2018, critically analyzing them, based on excusability of the supplier’s error and its recognoscibility by the consumer, nothing that we are not faced with a kind of advertising other than misleading and that the use of it is unnecessary, a matter that affects The scope of Law 19.496 on the Protection of Consumer Rights, since there being a supplier error, recognized by the supplier there is no trust to protect, so civil law must to returned to.
-
Property quality and consumer safety
The present commentary analyses the case Servicio Nacional del Consumidor con Inmobiliaria Francisco de Aguirre Limitada, in particular the judgments of the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court on the occasion of the hearing of an appeal and, later, cassation on the merits; which dealt with the scope of application of Law No. 19,496 on the Protection of Consumer Rights. To this end, and after briefly summarizing the facts, we will explain the legal problem posed by the concepts of quality and safety and their relationship with the applicable regulations. In turn, we will present the arguments of the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court in this regard, with special consideration of the dissenting vote of the Member Attorney Ms. Chaimovich on distinguishing the rights of safety from the quality of housing within the consumer relationship. With this, we intend to achieve an adequate understanding of the matters excluded from the law and the distinction between the rights it protects.
-
A CONCEPTUAL APPROACH BETWEEN THE DAMAGE AND ITS IMPORTANCE IN THE DIES A QUO OF THE STATUTE OF LIMITATION IN THE TORTS DAMAGE ACTION. A NECESSARY PROPOSAL REGARDING OF ARTICLE 2235 OF THE ECUADORIAN CIVIL CODE
In Ecuadorian Law, article 2235 of the Civil Code offers an answer regarding the accounting for the statute of limitations in the action for torts. However, the rule generates a discussion when certain cases are not covered or protected by the classical interpretation. The foundational interpretative rule understands that the calculation of the prescription must be from the verification of the wrongful act, understanding that the act has been perpetrated there. Nevertheless, this provision does not contemplate all types of damage, specifically hidden damage, and continued damage. This generates a conflict between the rule of the Torts Law that all damages must be compensated against the security in the legal relationships that the Statute of limitation seeks. Therefore, it is necessary to delimit the concept of compensable damage to understand and know how these types of damages have been conceived according to their consummation in time from an Ecuadorian conception. Accordingly, it will be possible to analyze the statute of limitation and how it has acted in case law and comparative law. In which, there is already a solution that determines the beginning of the statute of limitation in each case of hidden damage and continuing damage. In this way, a current solution will be proposed for the calculation of the statute of limitation in Ecuador.