Search Results
Search Results
-
THE JUDGE’S POWERS IN CONTROLLING THE PROCEDURE AS A GUARANTEE OF THE PRO ACTIONE PRINCIPLE
This paper analyzes the judgment pronounced by the Supreme Court, dated January 4, 2021, in case roll n ° 5493-2020, entitled “Z. with Talcahuano Health Service”, referring to the importance of the function that complies with the court in controlling the correctness of the procedure as a way of guaranteeing due process of law.
-
Related parties’ credits included in a mercantile current account and faithfulness of financial statements. Comment of the Supreme Court’s judgement of July 31, 2020, N. 29.982-2019
The paper analyzes a Supreme Court’s judgement which confirmed, with a reduction, the fines imposed on managers of a public corporation by the former SVS. The firm reported in the financial statements some long-term credits, which debtors where related companies. It did not take steps to collect them in a considerable period of time, on the grounds that they had been included into a mercantile current account with few movements. The supervisor reclassified the credits as long-term, and concluded that the financial statements contained false information. An analysis validates critically this judicial decision, and offers an alternative basis for it, built on the content of the commercial current account contract.
-
ABOUT THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS IN ELECTRONIC CONTRACTING BASED ON THE IMBALANCE IN THE RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS OF THE PARTIES
This comment analyzes the sentences handed down by virtue of an action in defense of the collective interest initiated by SERNAC aimed at declaring the abusiveness of the terms and conditions set forth on the website of an e-commerce platform, to which consumers had to adhere at the time to make your purchases. The study focuses on reasoning, in light of the criteria established in article 16 letter g) of Law No. 19,496, carried out in the different instances and by the Supreme Court when examining the clauses referring to the right of withdrawal; the formation of consent in electronic contracting and the rules on competition in the face of conflicts suffered by consumers.
-
UNFAIR COMPETITION BY FAULT
The article examines the unlawfulness in acts of unfair competition, pro- vided as a hypothesis of non-contractual civil liability in Law No. 20.169, which regulates unfair competition. Refuting an interpretation made by national scholars and courts, which states that such illicit requires proof of a fraudulent behavior, the article argues how the text of this law, the reliable history of its establishment, its systematic interpretation with others normative bodies (in particular, with the consumer protection that underlies as a legitimate interest expressly in this special law), the consideration of certain comparative experience and, even, a recent jurisprudence of the Supreme Court, allow to sustain in a well-founded manner that a conduct of unfair competition that infringes the ordinary diligence (slight fault) configures that illicit and gives rise to the exercise of the actions that this law establishes.
-
CROSS-BORDER DIVORCES AND INTERNATIONAL JURISDICTION: THE SPANISH SUPREME COURT DOCTRINE
International divorces are becoming more frequent every day. In many cases, there is a special interest for the parties in litigating before the courts of a certain State; the “forum shopping” mechanism is acquiring special relevance in order to obtain the most favorable forum, in particular regarding the applicable Law. Currently the main rule for international jurisdiction in the European Union is founded on Regulation 2201/2003. Its section 3 contains a wide number of grounds of jurisdiction for this purpose. The application of this Regulation has displaced the Spanish internal rules (section 22, Organic Act on the Judiciary 1985). Concerning the application of the mentioned Regulation, the Supreme Court has addressed some controversial issues related to the determination of the international jurisdiction of Spanish courts on divorces.
-
THE ENTIRE AGREEMENT CLAUSE OR INTEGRATION CLAUSE IN THE CHILEAN LAW OF CONTRACTS
This paper deals with the entire agreement clause in the Chilean law of contracts. It argues that the entire agreement clause has the function of promoting legal certainty, by precisely defining the terms and conditions of the contract based on the intention of the parties. The legal effect of the clause is to limit the declarations, promises and binding agreements to what is stated in the text of the signed contractual document, depriving all preliminary and contemporary communications to the signing of the contractual document of legal effect to integrate the terms and conditions of the contract. It further argues that the entire agreement clause has no impact on the criteria for contractual interpretation, on the implications of an implied term, on liability for misrepresentation, and on future variations or modifications of the contract. Lastly, it is argued that the clause is generally valid in the Chilean law of contracts, except in consumer law.