Search Results
Search Results
-
LEGITIMATION AND PUBLICITY REGARDING THE REGISTRATION OF A SEPARATION OF GOODS AGREEMENT
The Supreme Court rejected an appeal on the merits filed to reverse the dismissal of a third-party possession. The basis for this decision was that the act of awarding the rights to a property because of the liquidation of a community derived from a conjugal community and the payment of an alimony for which a person transferred the remaining percentage of rights to favor of their ex-spouse required a differentiated treatment, distinguishing it from the separate property agreement entered in the same instrument. Specifically, the discussion focused on the role of registry entry with respect to adjudication, which the third party considered was expressly required by law, but whose origin results from the general rules that inform the Chilean registry system, without forgetting the particularities of the conjugal community regime.
-
The business behind death. Park cemeteries as non-traditional financial suppliers
This article presents a commentary about the decisión of the 3rd Local Police Court of Maipú, confirmed by the Supreme Court, in which, after analyzing various elements of the promise of sale that the consumer contracted with a cemetery, it was determined that the business was, actually, similar to a leasing, and included the provision of a financial product, being possible to apply rules of Law No. 18.010 in conjunction with Law No. 19.496.
Although this qualification allows greater protection to the consumer against what may be considered a hidden financial product, the concept of “direct credit” allows a better explanation of the contract, allowing to understand that the operation carried out is a money loan, but it’s granted in a fictional way to the consumer.
-
Defects that prevent the enjoyment of leased goods. Supreme Court, July 7th 2020, nº. 8.214-2018
This work analyses a recent decision which limits the lessor’s obligation to deliver to the physical availability of goods that match the agreed description and specifications, notwithstanding the fact that the goods presents from the outset such defects that make its use by the lessee impossible. Such outcome contrasts with the legal opinions and case law of the last years, which often grant a broad interpretation of the obligations of the lessor regarding defects of leased goods. Nonetheless, the decision offers elements which allow to determine in which cases the lessee deserves a protection that goes beyond the literal terms of the contract.
-
Compensation of “pure” emotional distress claimed by secondary victims. A comparative overview of english and french law. case comment: chilean Supreme Court, january 24, 2019, n° 38037-2017
Moving away from the traditional cases dealing with death or injury of the primary victim, the Chilean Supreme Court compensated the non-pecuniary losses suffered by the wife and children of a man who was wrongly accused of being the author of a crime in the evening news emission of a national television broadcaster. A review of the current framework of protection given to honour and reputation will be useful to assess the structure of the compensation of non-pecuniary losses, distinguishing between normative and consequential ones, as well as highlighting to what extent “pure” moral losses are redressed. Additionally, the limitations imposed by other jurisdictions such as English and French law will be outlined, focusing on both the cases where secondary victims can claim such losses, as well as the restrictions imposed on the class of persons who can make such claims. All this will expose how the Chilean legal system shows signs of being one of the most liberal of the world regarding the breadth of the compensation of non-pecuniary losses, this being only one example among many others.
-