Search Results
Search Results
-
ON THE OPP ORTUNITY TO CLAIM THE ABANDONMENT OF THE PROCEDURE: THE CRITERION OF THE THIRD CHAMBER OF THE SUPREME COURT
Classic doctrine and jurisprudence understand that the abandonment of the procedure has no time limit for its filing, as long as an enforceable judgment has not been ruled on. Thus, the general rule on the time limit for the filing of incidents, set out in Article 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure, is not applicable to it. However, a series of rulings handed down by the Third Chamber of the Supreme Court have changed this approach. Based on an argumentative evolution, which began with an argument of procedural good faith, this Chamber has considered that the rule of article 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure is applicable to the incident of abandonment of the procedure. The aim of this paper is to show this evolution and to give an account of the problems of interpretation that can arise when considering this rule applicable.
-
IMPUTATION IN THE ABANDONMENT OF THE PROCEDURE AND INTERPRETATION OF ITS RULES
The paper analyzes a judgment issued by the Supreme Court in which the ma- jority vote, on the occasion of a judicial remedy, qualified the service of the decision that declared the evidentiary period initiated to only one of the parties, as a useful and suitable measure to interrupt the six-month period of Article 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure that regulates the abandonment of the procedure. In particular, the arguments put forward by the majority vote are examined, cha- llenging: i) The reference to the pro actione principle as a reason for restrictively interpreting the rules of abandonment of the procedure; ii) The use of the hy- pothetical suppression criterion in the analysis of the usefulness of an action; iii) The understanding that a greater number of parties in a procedure represents a reason to argue that there is no legal requirement to serve all the parties with the evidence resolution within a six-month period. Likewise, the consequences of sustaining the position of the majority vote are analyzed.