Top
RCHDP

Search Results

65 Results
Showing 43-48 matching the phrase case law.

Search Results

  • THE SYSTEM OF DAMAGE-LIMITING CLAUSES: INVENTORY AND PERSPECTIVES

    Thomas Genicón

    Liability provisions in contract law have led to feverish debate in France. Initially, French law granted validity to provisions limiting or excluding liability even while barring such applications in the case of malicious intent or gross negligence. however, on October 22, 1996, the situation changed when the commercial division of the French Cour de Cassation handed down its ruling in the Chronopost case.

    This article will review the current status of clauses restricting damages, the recent application of Chronopost jurisprudence and perspectives for the future of such provisions.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • FUNDAMENTALS OF GERMAN MEDICAL LIABILITY LAW IN THE FIELD OF AESTHETIC SURGERY

    Markus Finn

    The German medical liability law makes a distinction between the responsibility for treatment mistakes and responsibility for lack of information. Interventions in aesthetic surgery is, as a rule, a medical practice when the physician is below the standard in force in the respective special field of aesthetic plastic surgery. However, in the case of lack of information liability (tort) is based on bodily injury, according to the jurisdiction of German courts is inherent in any medical intervention in body or health status of the patient. However, bodily injury is not considered unlawful if the patient, after having been duly informed, has given valid consent (informed consent). Informed consent, which the treating party should give evidence at trial, can justify the bodily injury. In the aesthetic operations it is of practical importance, above all, the responsibility for insufficient information on the risks of the respective intervention. If aesthetic surgery, as no medical indication occurs often, the requirements for patient information are particularly stringent. In this sense, the jurisdiction requires a extensive, intense and sometimes “thoughtless” information about imminent risks, in the case of offset to some extent the purely “aesthetic indication” by the qualified patient consent after extensive information (intensely informed consent ). If it is found that the information was insufficient, doctors and hospitals may be liable for damages and ordered to pay compensation for personal injury.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • Fitzpatrick, Brian T. (2019). The Conservative Case For Class Actions. Chicago: The University Of Chicago Press. 271 pp.

    Claudio Fuentes Maureira

    Esta ha sido una obra polémica en su país de origen. Como bien es sabido, en Estados Unidos el régimen de acciones colectivas desde hace muchos años ha sido objeto de un intenso debate y crítica. En dicho contexto fallos de la Corte Suprema estadounidense –en su mayoría conservadora– han dado inicio a su futura muerte, en especial en materia consumo. En este debate quienes de manera más fuerte han criticado esta herramienta procesal, haciendo un intenso lobby para su reforma e idealmente su supresión, ha sido la derecha republicana y el empresariado. Es por ello que el presente libro ha generado controversia, ya que es un republicano quien ha salido en defensa (moderada, por cierto) de las acciones colectivas.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • Compensation of “pure” emotional distress claimed by secondary victims. A comparative overview of english and french law. case comment: chilean Supreme Court, january 24, 2019, n° 38037-2017

    Arantxa Gutiérrez

    Moving away from the traditional cases dealing with death or injury of the primary victim, the Chilean Supreme Court compensated the non-pecuniary losses suffered by the wife and children of a man who was wrongly accused of being the author of a crime in the evening news emission of a national television broadcaster. A review of the current framework of protection given to honour and reputation will be useful to assess the structure of the compensation of non-pecuniary losses, distinguishing between normative and consequential ones, as well as highlighting to what extent “pure” moral losses are redressed. Additionally, the limitations imposed by other jurisdictions such as English and French law will be outlined, focusing on both the cases where secondary victims can claim such losses, as well as the restrictions imposed on the class of persons who can make such claims. All this will expose how the Chilean legal system shows signs of being one of the most liberal of the world regarding the breadth of the compensation of non-pecuniary losses, this being only one example among many others.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • Material damage due to expropriation, beyond the cost of replacement of the expropriated property. Comment on the case Inmobiliaria Alameda S.A. with Servicio de Vivienda y Urbanización Metropolitano, Corte Suprema, 2020

    Patricio Ponce Correa

    This paper comments on a judgment of the Supreme Court and deals with the content of the expropriation compensation, regarding pecuniary damage. The foregoing, in order to indicate that said content is not limited to compensating the loss of property, but that, by virtue of the constitutional rule, it also includes any other effective damaging patrimonial consequence caused to the owner, as a direct and immediate consequence of the expropriation. 

    Thus, in a partial expropriation, in addition to the replacement cost of the expropriated property, the compensation may include the cost of the material damage caused to the existing buildings in the non-expropriated fraction of the property, as long as it is verified as an immediate and direct consequence of the expropriation, and the subsequent concretion of the works that motivate the ablatory act.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • The effects of discharge over third party securities

    Guillermo Caballero Germain, Juan Luis Goldenberg Serrano

    This paper analyzes the effects of the discharge over securities granted by third parties in favor of an insolvent debtor. The thesis we support is that discharge is a personal legal benefit granted to the insolvent debtor, who shall have a substantive defense in case any of its creditors intends to collect any balance of a pre-bankruptcy claim. Due to its personal nature, such defense does not benefit any third-party guarantor.

    PDF (Español (España))
Advanced filters
Published After
Published Before