Search Results
Search Results
-
CRITERIA FOR THE ASSESSMENT OF MORAL DAMAGES: A VIEW FROM CHILEAN CASE LAW
This article provides a critical assessment of the criteria employed by Chilean courts to justify the amount awarded for moral damages. Based on an analysis of a series of judgments recognizing such damages, the decisions are classified according to the central argument relied upon by the court in determining the quantum of compensation. Although this classification may be debatable in some cases, given that the decisive reasoning is not always explicit, the selection process is made transparent through cross-references provided in the footnotes. The initial classification criteria were drawn from legal scholarship and subsequently supplemented with additional criteria identified during the jurisprudential review. This study makes it possible to distinguish between argumentative practices that are consistent with the rules and principles of civil liability and those that deviate from them, thereby contributing to a clearer understanding of which criteria are legally sound and which are deficient.
-
THE AUTONOMY OF DAMAGES IN THE RECENT NATIONAL CASE LAW: A PARADIGM SHIFT?
The current work aims to tackle the autonomy of damages compensation for breach of contract within the current national precedent, by analyzing, systematizing and determining the pertinence of the premises and arguments that have been cited by the national courts to hold autonomy damages against breach of a debtor, getting away from the judicial reasoning which, for decades has postulated that this remedy could only be demanded as an accessory action or remedy, concurrent or supplementary to the aspiration of specific performance remedy or termination of contract.
-
THE DECEIVED BUYER, THE FRAUDS TER’S BANK AND THE LIMITS OF THE CLAIM FOR PROFITS FOR SOMEONE ELSE’S FRAUD
This commentary analyses a decision which narrows down the scope of the claim for profits derived from someone else’s fraud. This offers a clear contrast against the backdrop of recent case law, which established very general requirements for such claims. The decision granted special attention to the notion of “profit” of articles 1458 and 2316 of the CC. Accordingly, this commentary reviews the scope of this provisions based on their historical origin and practical outcomes. Additionally, the commentary critically approaches the relationship between the aforementioned articles and the claims that can be brought by those who suffered the consequences of the fraud.
-
NATURE AND REQUIREMENTS OF THE PROVISORY PERSONAL CARE IN JUDGMENTS BEFORE THE FAMILY COURTS
This article deals with the resolution of conflicts over the provisional personal care of NNA, qualifying it as an innovative precautionary measure in ordinary trial regulated by the LTF. Based on the new printed approach to the legal statute applicable by Law No. 20.680 of June 21, 2013, and for methodological purposes, the author addresses the matter by separating judgments followed between parents, from those initiated between a third party against of one or both parents, and also -situation not resolved- when the third custodian is sued by the parents in case the personal care of the NNA has been judicially attributed in previous lawsuit. The need to resort to the standard of the best interests of the child as a guiding criterion in the three cases, but differentiating the cause of asking according to the case, is underlined. Finally, the provisional personal care decreed in ordinary trial is distinguished from the precautionary measure contemplated in the procedure on protection measures.
-
Work in platform companies: subordination and beyond
Accelerated technological change involves relevant transformations for salaried labour, since it allows the introduction of adjusted forms of production –just in time–, which connect them in real time and on line with demand and consumption. The paradigmatic case of this transformation is the work carried out for platform companies, particularly in the form of delivery of goods or provision of services. This way of working, as we will review in this article, causes important legal challenges for Labour Law: on the one hand, the traditional problem of labour qualification for those who provide services in this modality; and, on the other hand, the regulation of the content of the labour relationship to which it gives rise, being particularly complex –due to its social and political implications– what is related to the duration and continuity of the workday. The correct resolution of these challenges, we will argue, will determine an important part of the fate of the new ways of working and the freedom of the employees involved.
-
FORFEITURE CLAUSES AS A MANIFESTATION OF A PARTY’S POWER TO TERMINATE A CONTRACT
The treatment afforded to resolutory clauses by Chilean legislation is limited to their express incorporation into forfeiture clauses inherent in purchase and sale agreements. Such little regulation, coupled with the limited use spared to them by Chilean legal scholars, much like the codifier did, trans- lates into a narrow application to cases of contract non-performance.
That is why, by resorting to such historical background, books of au- thority and case law as may be relevant, this paper aims to determine the legal nature of forfeiture clauses and how they operate in order to better their use as a contractual remedy in the interest of unpaid creditors.