Top
RCHDP

Search Results

17 Results
Showing 1-6 matching the phrase culpa.

Search Results

  • APRECIACIÓN DE LA CULPA EN MATERIA CIVIL

    Pablo Rodríguez Grez

    La apreciación de la culpa constituye un problema central de la responsabilidad civil. Aquélla se vincula de manera indisoluble a la conducta del deudor, lo que conlleva a entender la obligación como un deber de conducta tipificado en la ley. A partir de esta idea se distingue la obligación de la prestación, lo que permite descartar la admisión de obligaciones de resultado, ya que el deudor podrá siempre excluir la responsabilidad probando que ha sido diligente. La culpa, ya sea contractual o extracontractual, requiere una comparación con un modelo preestablecido de conducta, siendo aplicable la apreciación in abstracto. Esto no significa, sin embargo, que exista una identidad en la apreciación de la culpa en ambas ramas de la responsabilidad civil. La diferencia estriba en que la culpa contractual ostenta parámetros fuertes para apreciarla; en cambio, en la culpa extracontractual la apreciación resulta más flexible.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • The reception of the creation of unauthorized risks in chilean law, as a criterion for objective imputation, can it be distinguished from fault?

    Cristián Aedo Barrena

    This paper explores the confluences between causality and fault. Once it is considered that causality is not satisfied only with material or factual criteria, and that it must necessarily be assisted with normative criteria, the doctrine has raised the confluence of fault and the creation of unauthorized risks, normative criterion of the imputation objective, of German origin. Based on this analysis, it is proposed to distinguish between commissive and omisive causality and it is proposed that, in both cases, fault operates as a mechanism to aid causality.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • THE BORDER BETWEEN VICTIM’S EXCLUSIVE FAULT AND CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE ON THE BASIS OF CHILEAN JURISPRUDENCE

    Lilian San Martín Neira

    This article refers to the victim’s fault in its two aspects: exclusive fault of the victim and contributory negligence. On the basis of the Chilean Supreme Court jurisprudence, it demonstrates that they correspond to two separate institutions, which play different roles in judgment of civil liability. Exclusive fault is an argument to prove the absence of liability of the defendant, but it doesn’t entail a legal analysis of the victim’s conduct, but only a factual explanation for agent’s conduct. Contributory negligence, instead, presupposes the defendant’s liability, that’s why it requires such legal analysis. In this case, is necessary to demonstrate that with respect to the victim’s conduct concur the legal requisites to elevate it from a simple condition to a cause of the accident, according to standard causality criteria. These requisites are not addressed in this paper.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • HEALTHCARE LIABILITY DUE TO MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE. A PROPOSAL FOR SYSTEMATIZATION

    Cristian Eduardo Aedo Barrena

    This article aims to systematize the liability of public and private health institutions as a result of medical negligence, through a dogmatic analysis of the problem and the decisions of seventy rulings selected for the study, as they substantiate such liability in various ways or resolve different systematic assumptions. The article includes a conclusions section that highlights the main findings of the study.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • THE EVENT GIVING RISE TO CONTRACT NON-PERFORMANCE AND SECTION 1547 OF THE CHILEAN CIVIL CODE

    Santiago Urrejola Santa María

    By merely construing the sections in our Civil Code and, in particular, Section 1547 thereof, Chilean legal scholars point out that the event giving rise to contract non-performance, that is to say, one of the factors to establish contract liability, arises upon the presence of two elements: failure to fulfill an obligation due and the fact that such failure hails from fraudulent or negligent conduct on the part of the debtor, the debtor’s negligence being an essential element of contract liability. Throughout this paper, we intend to show that contract liability as set forth in the Civil Code may arise in the absence of the second element, that is to say, without fraud or negligence on the part of the debtor, and that, therefore, the scope of application of Section 1547 of theCivil Code is limited to the failure to fulfill certain obligations to perform an act only, which means that it is not general in nature. As a result, depending on the type of obligation, the Civil Code provides for both an event giving rise to contract non-performance based on the debtor’s negligence, leading to subjective contract liability, and another event which makes no value judgment on the debtor’s conduct, leading to objective contract liability.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • ON THE ADVANTAGES OF LIMITING THE EFFECTS OF THE DIVIDE BETWEEN DUTIES TO ACHIEVE A SPECIFIC RESULT AND DUTIES OF BEST EFFORTS ON THE ROLE AND BURDEN OF PROVING THE DEBTOR’S FAULT

    Pablo Letelier Cibié

    The distinction between duties to achieve a specific result and duties of best efforts has given place to important uncertainties in Chilean law, particularly regarding the role and burden of proving the debtor’s fault. In part, these uncertainties are a consequence of the difficulties in reconciling the idea of duties of best efforts with the limit that Chilean law imposes between obligation and liability for breach of contract. After reviewing the position of case law and legal scholarship in this regard, this paper suggests that the recognition of duties of best efforts in Chilean law does not require to accept its alleged consequences in the role and burden of proving the debtor’s fault.

Advanced filters
Published After
Published Before