Search Results
Search Results
-
THE CASSATION APPEAL IN PLENARY SESSION: AN ASSESSMENT AFTER THIRTY YEARS
Article 780 of the code of civil procedure, incorporated into Law No. 19374 of February 18, 1995, which allows the Supreme Court in plenary session to hear cassation appeals in cases of jurisprudential dispersion originating within the Court itself, has been scarcely applied, and its impact on the development of generalized guidelines for the interpretation of laws affecting civil and commercial matters is practically nil. This was anticipated early on by some Chilean legal scholars. What these scholars failed to foresee is that, in the few cases where the Supreme Court in plenary session heard cassation appeals, subsequent lower courts would disregard the doctrines established by the Court without further explanation, thus calling into question not only equality before the law but also the predictability of the interpretation and application of important institutions of Chilean private law. The article offers an explanation of how the aforementioned results were obtained and concludes with a defense of the jurisprudence unification purposes underlying this procedural mechanism.
-
Family, disability and succession. Some ideas for a new chilean Constitution
This paper aims to propose that the new Constitution should established in a special way the protection of minors descendants and disabled people as members of the Family. In accordance with this, and based on the existence of freedom of disposition of the deceased through the rules of succession due to death, it will be argued that restrictions on that freedom must be based not on the social function of property, but rather the protection of family members whenever they are descendants or persons with disabilities, thus justifying the transition from a forced allocation with a hereditary nature to one of a maintenance nature, as has been proposed in some compared systems.