Search Results
Search Results
-
The reception of the creation of unauthorized risks in chilean law, as a criterion for objective imputation, can it be distinguished from fault?
This paper explores the confluences between causality and fault. Once it is considered that causality is not satisfied only with material or factual criteria, and that it must necessarily be assisted with normative criteria, the doctrine has raised the confluence of fault and the creation of unauthorized risks, normative criterion of the imputation objective, of German origin. Based on this analysis, it is proposed to distinguish between commissive and omisive causality and it is proposed that, in both cases, fault operates as a mechanism to aid causality.
-
THE INCREASING RISK AS A COMPLEMENTARY CRITERION TO THE CREATION OF UNAUTHORIZED RISK IN CAUSATION IN LAW. AN ANALYSIS IN MEDICAL LAW
This paper, focused on medical liability, is intended to analyze how causation by omissions works. We affirm that the fault, in terms of creating a not allowed risk, is identified with the normative approach. Notwithstanding the foregoing, said intellectual projection of guilt and, consequently, of cau- sation by omissions context, is possible to be answered through other approaches. In this sense, it is proposed to address the objective imputation criterion called increased risk (also known as lawful alternative conduct). It is considered that the aforementioned concept is useful in contexts in which the guilty omission cannot be considered as the cause of the damage, since if the behavior under question had not been omitted, the tort would have taken place anyway. Hence, the creation of impermissible risks can be taken as a presumption of causation in law susceptible to defensible contradictory reasoning.
-
THE PROBLEM OF CAUSATION IN THE LAW OF CIVIL LIABILITY
From both the theoretical and practical perspectives, causation is undoubtedly the thorniest and perhaps least-addressed issue in civil liability law. Convoluted, difficult, complex, turbulent, insoluble, distressing, multifaceted, enigmatic and ambiguous are some of the features (or adjectives) that commonly identify the qualities (abstract) attributed to causality (as noun). Nevertheless, the distinction between causality and objective imputation has re-emerged with considerable fanfare in recent years in Criminal Law, providing a breath of fresh air well worth examining.