Search Results
Search Results
-
Compensation of “pure” emotional distress claimed by secondary victims. A comparative overview of english and french law. case comment: chilean Supreme Court, january 24, 2019, n° 38037-2017
Moving away from the traditional cases dealing with death or injury of the primary victim, the Chilean Supreme Court compensated the non-pecuniary losses suffered by the wife and children of a man who was wrongly accused of being the author of a crime in the evening news emission of a national television broadcaster. A review of the current framework of protection given to honour and reputation will be useful to assess the structure of the compensation of non-pecuniary losses, distinguishing between normative and consequential ones, as well as highlighting to what extent “pure” moral losses are redressed. Additionally, the limitations imposed by other jurisdictions such as English and French law will be outlined, focusing on both the cases where secondary victims can claim such losses, as well as the restrictions imposed on the class of persons who can make such claims. All this will expose how the Chilean legal system shows signs of being one of the most liberal of the world regarding the breadth of the compensation of non-pecuniary losses, this being only one example among many others.
-
CARTEL AND CIVIL LIABILITY FOR COLLECTIVE DAMAGE TO CONSUMERS
It addresses the central issues of liability for collective or diffuse damages caused by cartel to consumers. Specifically, standing of consumers (requirement of “contractual link” and incidence of the free competition judgment), culpability and damage (nature, quantification and causality).
-
Ordinary possessory injunctions and the concept of possession in the civil code
The Supreme Court accepted an appeal on the merits and gave rise to a restitutory injunction through which the owner of real state asked that the use of a passage adjacent to her property be restored and it belonged in common to all the neighbors. On this passage there was a transit easement that benefited the good in common and was established in the neighboring co-owners. The Court considered that the restitutory injunction is aimed at recovering the material possession of a registered real estate of which the plaintiff has been deprived. With a divided vote, the compensation for damages requested by the plaintiff was rejected, because the damages claimed were not proven.
-
SOME CONSIDERATIONS RELATED TO THE CHILEAN MARITIME TRANSPORTATION CONTRACT UNDER THE BILL OF LADING REGIME FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF THE NEW CONTRACT LAW
The new Contract Law that has emerged from the CISG has meant a change in the way of conceiving the contract, the breach and the way of structuring the contract remedies in case of breach. In this way, the modern doctrine has made its efforts to prove that the rules of the new Contract Law can be applied in Chile and, therefore, the remedies in case of contract breach are also applicable. In this context, the present work aims to analyze the Chilean maritime transportation contract under the Bill of Lading regime from the perspective of the new Contract Law and to examine how this new conception influences the notion of breach and the remedies in case of contract breach, emphasizing the compensation remedy.