Search Results
Search Results
-
THE ADJUSTABILITY OF COURT-ORDERED MONETARY JUDGMENTS IN CONTRACTUAL AND EXTRACONTRACTUAL LAW. A DOGMATIC ANALYSIS OF OBLIGATIONS OF SUM AND VALUE AND AN EMPIRICAL STUDY OF JUDICIAL BEHAVIOR
The aim of this paper is to explain the asymmetry of judicial decisions con- cerning the date of accrual of the readjustment of judicial sentence to a sum of money in cases of breach of contract and torts using dogmatic concepts and tools of the legal theory. Without basing itself on these, judicial practice assumes in the interpretation of the law the categories of obligations of sum and value and of being obliged and being liable. To do so, we analyzed seventy one cassation judgments of the First Chamber of the Supreme Court, randomly chosen and handed down between 2008 and 2023. All of them condemn to a sum of money, either as compensation for damages (contractual or non-contractual) or for the return of a non-paid debt, but assume different criteria on the different periods for the accrual of the adjustment granted. Despite the disparity of criteria, there is, in broad terms, a certain uniformity, which is consistent with the jurisprudential category that distinguishes between obligations of sum and of value. This paper aims to show that this coherence is not the product of chance, but that the judiciary intuitively adopts decisions that reflect these jurisprudential categories when interpreting the law. Finally, we intend to collaborate with the effective development of a practice of following precedents, which is essential in a State governed by the rule of law, by showing its necessity and possibility.
-
DAMAGES RESULTING FROM DIVORCE (DOCTRINE AND JURISPRUDENCE IN ARGENTINA)
This paper seeks to examine the scholarly and jurisprudential developments in Argentina concerning compensation for damages caused by divorce. Traditionally, Family Law was deemed impervious to the rules of tort. however, in recent years a new hermeneutic has appeared which applies the general principles of civil liability to damages arising from family relationships, and especially the losses caused by divorce.
The paper takes into account developments in case law, scholarly writing and reforms to the Civil Code and the various solutions proposed to amalgamate the particular characteristics of family relations and family law, and the changes in the framework of modern law of damages.
The paper addresses each option for liability (in contract or tort) and notes applicable jurisprudence.
-
FUNDAMENTALS OF GERMAN MEDICAL LIABILITY LAW IN THE FIELD OF AESTHETIC SURGERY
The German medical liability law makes a distinction between the responsibility for treatment mistakes and responsibility for lack of information. Interventions in aesthetic surgery is, as a rule, a medical practice when the physician is below the standard in force in the respective special field of aesthetic plastic surgery. However, in the case of lack of information liability (tort) is based on bodily injury, according to the jurisdiction of German courts is inherent in any medical intervention in body or health status of the patient. However, bodily injury is not considered unlawful if the patient, after having been duly informed, has given valid consent (informed consent). Informed consent, which the treating party should give evidence at trial, can justify the bodily injury. In the aesthetic operations it is of practical importance, above all, the responsibility for insufficient information on the risks of the respective intervention. If aesthetic surgery, as no medical indication occurs often, the requirements for patient information are particularly stringent. In this sense, the jurisdiction requires a extensive, intense and sometimes “thoughtless” information about imminent risks, in the case of offset to some extent the purely “aesthetic indication” by the qualified patient consent after extensive information (intensely informed consent ). If it is found that the information was insufficient, doctors and hospitals may be liable for damages and ordered to pay compensation for personal injury.
-
THE DECEIVED BUYER, THE FRAUDS TER’S BANK AND THE LIMITS OF THE CLAIM FOR PROFITS FOR SOMEONE ELSE’S FRAUD
This commentary analyses a decision which narrows down the scope of the claim for profits derived from someone else’s fraud. This offers a clear contrast against the backdrop of recent case law, which established very general requirements for such claims. The decision granted special attention to the notion of “profit” of articles 1458 and 2316 of the CC. Accordingly, this commentary reviews the scope of this provisions based on their historical origin and practical outcomes. Additionally, the commentary critically approaches the relationship between the aforementioned articles and the claims that can be brought by those who suffered the consequences of the fraud.
-
COMPENSATORY DAMAGES FOR BREACH OF BILATERAL CONTRACTS AS AN AUTONOMOUS REMEDY IN CHILEAN PRIVATE LAW
The present work aims to determine if, while facing breach of contract, the creditor can opt indiscriminately among claiming the termination of the contract, specific performance, or damages compensation; or whether that choice is limited only to the termination of the contract or specific perfor- mance, in both cases together with damages compensation. In order to do that, this work also analyses the articles contained in the Chilean Civil Code and the model which the new contract law offers nowadays in this matter.