Search Results
Search Results
-
LA DONACIÓN MODAL EN EL DERECHO ESPAÑOL: EL INCUMPLIMIENTO DEL MODO ¿UNA CAUSA DE REVOCACIÓN PERPETUA?
La regulación de la revocación de las donaciones modales contenida en el Código Civil español es manifiestamente insuficiente, lo que genera no sólo numerosas interrogantes sobre la materia sino, también, que exista un elevado grado de litigiosidad ante los tribunales. En este trabajo se aborda la cuestión de si en el Derecho español el modo impuesto en una donación puede tener carácter perpetuo o si necesariamente debe tener carácter temporal (esto es, si transcurrido determinado plazo cumpliéndose el modo, debe entenderse que éste se ha cumplido y consumado y, por tanto, el donante no podrá ejercitar la acción de revocación de la donación del artículo 647 del CC, aunque el donatario quebrante el modo). Para obtener una respuesta y determinar, en su caso, cuál es el plazo que tiene que transcurrir para poder considerar que el modo se ha cumplido, se examina no sólo la normativa civil referente a la donación modal y la prohibición de vínculos perpetuos, también las normas sobre la cesión gratuita de bienes en el ámbito de las administraciones públicas (supuesto análogo a la donación modal). Asimismo, se realiza un exhaustivo análisis de la jurisprudencia de la jurisdicción civil y de la jurisdicción contencioso-administrativa sobre la materia, con la finalidad de extraer principios que ayuden a encontrar una respuesta al interrogante planteado.
-
Three issues of Law Nº 19,496 in a single case: the applicability to micro and small companies; the independence of infringement action from the compensation action and the expiration period of the legal warranty
This paper aims to exhibit three issues that have risen in Consumer Law as a result of the enforcement of Law Nº. 19,496 by our Courts of Justice. First, the enforcement of the protective statute by micro and small companies against their suppliers under the terms of Law No. 20,416. Second, the close dependency or autonomy between infringement liability and compensation, particularly under the hypotheses by which legal warranty operates. Lastly, the expiration period that characterizes the legal warranty as opposed to the general statute of limitations periods set forth in Article 26 of Law No. 19,496.
-
THE DIES A QUO ON EXTINCTIVE PRESCRIPTION IN THE CONTEXT OF DAMAGES ARISING FROM DEFECTIVE SANITARY PRODUCTS. A COMPARATIVE APPROACH
The extinctive prescription of the action for compensation for damage caused by defective medical devices is characterized by the complexity involved in determining the moment from which the period begins to run. This problem invites us to reflect on whether the computation of the limitation period will start from the consumption of the drug, or from the moment the damage manifests itself. In this paper, we propose to make a comparative exposition of the matter by reviewing our legal system, the French and the Spanish ones.
-
ABOUT THE SANCTION FOR UNFAIR TERMS IN CONSUMER LAW
This article examines the sanction applicable to unfair terms in Chilean consumer law, in light of a recent decision of the Supreme Court (Case No. 34713-2023), which classified as unfair an acceleration clause contained in a mortgage loan agreement. The judgment is of particular interest as it expressly resolves the doctrinal debate concerning the nature of the invalidity provided for in Article 16 of Law No. 19,496, holding that it amounts to absolute nullity. The article sets out the facts of the case, systematises the main doctrinal positions on the sanction for unfairness, and reviews the evolution of case law on the matter. Finally, the authors argue that the solution adopted by the Supreme Court is only partially correct, although it is commendable insofar as it is grounded in existing law: it recognises the public policy character of the control of unfair terms and allows for a coherent integration of the Consumer Protection Act with the general regime of nullity, without resorting to de lege ferenda constructions.
-
ON THE POSSIBILITY OF STAKEHOLDERS TO DEMAND THE PERFORMANCE OF SUSTAINABLE CLAUSES CONTAINED IN CONTRACTS BETWEEN BUSINESS AGENTS
Companies incorporate sustainability clauses in commercial contracts with other business organizations, in order to implement long-term social responsibility in business operations. These provisions generally do not grant sufficient coercive power for their enforceability, and, furthermore, make reference to external third parties (stakeholders) who may be affected by the commercial operation. This study aims to determinate if it is possible to reinterpret the stipulation in favor of a third party and the opposability of contracts by third parties in Chilean contract law to provide effectiveness to sustainability clauses regarding those who are not party to the agreement but are benefited by their observance. Accordingly, the hypothesis of this research is that stakeholders, as third-party beneficiaries of contractual clauses incorporated in the field of corporate sustainability, may enforce them as this allows for the achievement of the contract’s purpose or claim damages in the field of tort liability, as they are recognized a legitimate interest in CCS’ fulfillment.