Top
RCHDP

Search Results

9 Results
Showing 1-6 matching the phrase scope of application of the law.

Search Results

  • THE LOSS OF CHANCE DOCTRINE IN THE COMPARATIVE LAW HORIZON

    Hugo Alejandro Cardenas Villarreal

    The legal theory of loss of opportunity generates genuine fascination. While it has been accepted by several jurisdictions in recent years, it is still being debated in others that had previously accepted it. However, this notion’s popularity contrasts with the lack of clarity regarding its scope of application and legal regime, which has led to somewhat uncontrolled case law. Against this back drop, the present paper seeks to offer a comparative analysis of how the loss of opportunity theory is perceived and implemented in some of the most significant jurisdictions within the common law and civil law traditions. Despite the disparity of approaches observed in the comparative landscape, this paper identifies the rules on which there seems to be agreement, as well as the alternative solution that has been adopted by jurisdictions that have rejected the theory.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • EXCEPTION CLAUSES IN ARGENTINE PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW, WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO HISTORICAL AND COMPARATIVE ASPECTS

    Milton César Feuillade

    This paper examines the exception clauses in Argentine Private International Law, which were given legislative form in the Civil and Commercial Code in 2015. It identifies the comparative sources on which they draw and traces their origins, since our working hypothesis concerns their current operation and projected use by legal practitioners. Methodologically, the study relies on comparative case law, in light of the scarcity of domestic decisions. The article provides a structured analysis of the proximity principle and the exception clause, addressing their relationship, content, and scope, and proposes a typology. Building on their characteristics, comparative assessment, and the relevant scholarship, it advances proposals for their application. Among statutory models, Swiss law serves as a primary reference, and, in our view, the Belgian Code offers the most precise and modern formulation. The clause’s exceptional character is linked to outcomes that would otherwise be manifestly arbitrary or unsuitable for the case; it should be invoked only when necessary.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • THE SCOPE OF APPLICATION OF THE VIENNA CONVENTION ON THE INTERNATIONAL SALE OF GOODS AND ITS INTEGRATION BY THE CHILEAN PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW

    Francisco Grob Duhalde

    This article analyzes some of the most controversial issues that have arisen before Chilean Courts with regard to the scope of application of the CISG and the filling of its gaps (in the absence of general principles) through the application of Chilean choice-of-law rules. The article reviews the decisions of Chilean Courts on the territorial and material scope of application of the CISG; the law applicable to fill its gaps, including the law applicable to agency, limitation periods, property of the goods, burden of proof and the right to withhold performance; as well as the possibility of opting out of the CISG and the effects of the article 96 reservation made by Chile.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • Property quality and consumer safety

    Paula Godoy Muñoz, Ignacio Labra Saldías

    The present commentary analyses the case Servicio Nacional del Consumidor con Inmobiliaria Francisco de Aguirre Limitada, in particular the judgments of the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court on the occasion of the hearing of an appeal and, later, cassation on the merits; which dealt with the scope of application of Law No. 19,496 on the Protection of Consumer Rights. To this end, and after briefly summarizing the facts, we will explain the legal problem posed by the concepts of quality and safety and their relationship with the applicable regulations. In turn, we will present the arguments of the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court in this regard, with special consideration of the dissenting vote of the Member Attorney Ms. Chaimovich on distinguishing the rights of safety from the quality of housing within the consumer relationship. With this, we intend to achieve an adequate understanding of the matters excluded from the law and the distinction between the rights it protects.

    PDF (Español (España))
  • Case law on determining lex societatis of capital companies. From a spanish private international law perspective

    Laura García Álvarez

    The aim of this paper is to address the interpretation and scope of application of the article 9.11 of the Spanish Civil Code in order to determine the law applicable to legal persons, specially capital companies, and other issues such as their “nationality”, capacity to take part in legal proceedings, legal standing, responsibility or representation. This analysis will be done from a Spanish Private International Law perspective on the basis of a critical review of Spanish Supreme Court jurisprudence on this topic, which has had a key role on its development.


    PDF (Español (España))
  • The misleading advertising: a problem of provider excusability or consumer recognoscibility?

    Iñigo de la Maza, Patricia López Díaz

    The purpose of this work is to address what some of the judgments of our courts have come to call erroneous advertising in order to determinate whether, in fact, we are facing a new advertising category or, on the contrary, it constitutes the negative face of advertising misleading. The method used has been to review the judgments of the Santiago Courts of Appeal that have alluded to it between the years 2015 to 2018, critically analyzing them, based on excusability of the supplier’s error and its recognoscibility by the consumer, nothing that we are not faced with a kind of advertising other than misleading and that the use of it is unnecessary, a matter that affects The scope of Law 19.496 on the Protection of Consumer Rights, since there being a supplier error, recognized by the supplier there is no trust to protect, so civil law must to returned to.

    PDF (Español (España))
Advanced filters
Published After
Published Before