Search Results
Search Results
-
CREDITOR PROTECTION RULES IN UNDERCAPITALIZED LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANIES. CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND A PROPOSAL OF SOLUTION
This paper focuses on determining if it is possible (and desirable) to construe an implicit duty to adequately capitalize a company as a counterbalance for the limitation of the liability of the shareholders, especially when many compared legal systems have been increasingly deactivating the protective function of the capital toward the creditors. Even though creditor protection rules may be required in order to confront the shift of the risk toward them that such limitation imposes, we claim that this argument may only stand as long as it is supported by the existence of fiduciary duties of the shareholders and the management in favor of the creditors, mid or not by the debtor company, and that such duties arise from the proximity of the insolvency in undercapitalization scenarios. Nevertheless, the efficiency of the legal solutions structured over such implied duties may be questioned considering that, on the one hand, the security function of the capital has been diminished, and, on the other, that the economic science has not reached an agreement on the proper composition of the capital, so that legal certainty may be threatened by the said responses, destroying the justifications of the limited liability rules based in their social benefits.
-
Dissolution of a limited liability company due to resignation based on serious reason and absence of affectio societatis
The Court of Appeals of Talca, when reviewing a complaint appeal filed against an arbitration judgement derived from a demand for dissolution of a LLC, decides on its admissibility, based on the resignation for “serious reason” in the face of administrative mismanagement and the loss of the affectio societatis and the consequent termination of the company. In this context, the Court revokes the arbitration judgment, declares the company dissolved, and in the effort to achieve this task, conceptualizes and refers to the nature and place in the corporate structure of the affectio societatis, attributing to its absence a justifying character for the resignation of the partner. These observations deserve a critical analysis that could lead to a diverse conclusion from that reached by the Court.
-
-