Top
RCHDP

LEGAL PROVISIONS ON INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS: RULES OR MERE ADVICE?

Authors

Rodrigo Coloma Correa
Universidad Alberto Hurtado.
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3347-7625
Cristián Banfi del Río
Universidad de Chile.
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9932-9898
Claudio Agüero San Juan
Universidad Alberto Hurtado.
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7005-2979

Files

PDF (Español (España))

Abstract

This article addresses an old debate concerning the pragmatic dimension of legal provisions on contractual interpretation. The article uses a case decided in a dissenting manner by the lower courts and the Supreme Court as a common thread. It follows from our analysis that those provisions would not be rules (in a strong sense of bindingness), nor mere advice (in a sense of permissions), but they belong to the category of interpretation standards, that do not impose a result but a burden of justification, whether they are used or not. This form of understanding explains, prima facie, the Supreme Court’s power to modify decisions in cassation on the merits, and urges to deepen on what we understand by breach of law and error.

Details