Search Results
Search Results
-
The implications of the integrating function of good faith with respect to the obligation to deliver in the contract of sale: subversion, restriction and warranty
In light of an obiter dictum issued by the Supreme Court regarding the scope of the seller’s obligation to deliver, this work seeks to determine the legal implications of integrating, through the principle of good faith under Article 1546 of the Civil Code, the obligation to transfer ownership in the contract of sale. The central thesis is that such integration, as proposed by the Court, subverts the general rule concerning the scope of the seller’s obligation, restricts the regime of eviction, and transforms the obligation to deliver into one of warranty.
-
DUSTING OFF THE CIVIL CODE. ABOUT SERNAC’S EXECUTIVE RESOLUTION ON THE INCORPORATION OF DELIVERY DATES OF REAL ESTATE PROJECTS IN OMMUNICATIONS PRIOR TO THE SIGNING OF PURCHASE AND SALE PROMISES
Sernac’s Executive Resolution No. 277, issued on April 21, 2025, addresses the inclusion of delivery dates for real estate projects in communications prior to the signing of preliminary sales agreements. This article offers acritical analysis of the interpretative ruling, highlighting both its strengths and its conceptual ambiguities and normative limitations. It examines the legal nature of SERNAC’s circulars and rulings, their limited normative scope and legal effects, as well as the contractual consequences of breaching preliminary real estate agreements. The discussion also considers the role of Chilean civil law and, in particular, the application of Article 1554 of the Civil Code in promises subject to indeterminate conditions. The article concludes that, although the ruling reinforces certain valuable consumer protection elements, Sernac has missed a meaningful opportunity to clarify –more precisely and with greater technical rigour– the scope of real estate suppliers’ obligations.
-
DUTY TO SAFEGUARD RELEVANT INFORMATION IN THE PRE-CONTRACTUAL STAGE
The duty to provide information at the pre-contractual stage has not been the subject of much debate at present. However, it is worth mentioning that neither doctrine nor case law has sufficiently considered whether such data deserves any duty of care under common law. The purpose of this commentary on case law is to study the existing legal protection of this delivery of information in the pre-contractual stage and, specifically, the construction of the duty of care that protects certain assets. For this purpose, we will analyze the judgment in question, in which the use of information provided in the pre-contractual stage for the execution of a project in which the party that provided such data is not a party is alleged, and then characterize what type of information assets enjoy this special duty according to the criteria delimited by the Supreme Court in the sublite case.
-
Defects that prevent the enjoyment of leased goods. Supreme Court, July 7th 2020, nº. 8.214-2018
This work analyses a recent decision which limits the lessor’s obligation to deliver to the physical availability of goods that match the agreed description and specifications, notwithstanding the fact that the goods presents from the outset such defects that make its use by the lessee impossible. Such outcome contrasts with the legal opinions and case law of the last years, which often grant a broad interpretation of the obligations of the lessor regarding defects of leased goods. Nonetheless, the decision offers elements which allow to determine in which cases the lessee deserves a protection that goes beyond the literal terms of the contract.
-
LAW REPORT: VALIDITY OF AN USUFRUCT FOR NINETY YEARS IN FAVOR OF JOINT-STOCK COMPANY IN CHILEAN LAW
This law report provides an opinion on the following issues: the scope of application of the prohibition established in the final paragraph of article 770 of the Chilean Civil Code to establish usufructs that exceed 30 years; and the possibility of constituting a usufruct for a company for a period of 90 years over real estate. It is concluded that said prohibition established in article 770 is only applicable to corporations and foundations, and not for a joint-stock company; further, that a usufruct constituted for a period of 90 years in favor of a stock company over a real estate is perfectly valid in accordance to Chilean law, especially given that in our law it is possible that there are usufructs for more than 90 years, as well as other figures that allow the use and/or enjoyment of a thing to be transferred for 90 or more years and that have been used in practice without their terms having been considered excessive.
-
Exclusion of the right of withdrawal in online contracts with consumers in case of goods unsealed after delivery, not suitable to be returned for reasons of protection of health or hygiene
The right to withdraw from the contract is especially relevant today in the contracting of goods and services between businessmen and consumers, particularly in online contracting. In the Spanish legal system, such right is recognized in Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007, of November 16, which approves the consolidated text of the General Law for the Defense of Consumers and Users and other complementary laws. However, among the exclusions to the exercise of this right, the case of the supply of sealed goods not suitable to be returned for reasons of health protection or hygiene and that have been unsealed after delivery is contemplated. In the present work the elements of such exclusion are analyzed, the ineptitude of the good to be returned, characteristics of the “seal”, as well as information that must be provided to the consumer for the exclusion to operate, based on the sentence of the Court of Justice of the European Union, of March 27, 2019, case C 681/17, which admits the exercise by a consumer of the right of withdrawal in case of online purchase of a mattress that is unsealed for testing.