Search Results
Search Results
-
COMPARED RESOURSES RELATIVE TO THE DETERMINATION OF A CAUSAL LINK. AN ANALYSIS FOCUSED ON EVENTS RELATED TO HEALTH RESPONSABILY
The scientific certainty linked to technological development impacts on victims in this xxi century, particularly, in the accreditation of the causal link, which is always necessary to justify a tort action. Sensitive trials, many of them related to public health, largely shows the problem we intend to study. Comparative law has exposed this difficulty, arriving at solutions that show an interest into make flexible rules of evidence in favor of the proposed causality. We’ve found in our research the recourse to the solidarity responsibility, and to a lesser extent the proportionate responsibility, as well as the evidential presumptions by way of diverse mechanisms of causal inference. These solutions represent responses of legal adaptation which have been observed in order to provide guarantees to the damaged that, in a scientific doom scenario, has been affected twice: whether about their apparent damage, whether about the causal uncertainty that threatens her compensation.
-
CIVIL LIABILITY FOR DEFECTIVE PRODUCTS AND ‘DEVELOPMENT RISKS’ AS AN EXEMPTION: FROM THE REGULATORY FRAMEWORK ESTABLISHEDBY THE CHILEAN HEALTH CODE TO A GENERAL REGIME
This study examines the treatment that the national legislator has given to “development risks” in relation to civil liability for defective medical products, rejecting them as a ground for exemption from liability. Delving into the matter, it is questioned whether this exclusion should or should not be replicated in the formulation of a general regime for defective products, of which our national legal system still lacks. The search for an answer to this main question is supported by an analysis and evaluation of the benefits or disadvantages that the exclusion may pose for consumer interests, along with an analysis of the coherence of its establishment within a system of qualified strict liability and the potential issues it may raise in constructing the causal link.
-
THE JUDGE’S POWERS IN CONTROLLING THE PROCEDURE AS A GUARANTEE OF THE PRO ACTIONE PRINCIPLE
This paper analyzes the judgment pronounced by the Supreme Court, dated January 4, 2021, in case roll n ° 5493-2020, entitled “Z. with Talcahuano Health Service”, referring to the importance of the function that complies with the court in controlling the correctness of the procedure as a way of guaranteeing due process of law.
-
The air transport contract and the emergency by COVID-19: the chilean aeronautical statute front the cancellation of flights by force majeure and the reactivation of post-pandemic air traffic
The Coronavirus health emergency has paralyzed or slowed down an important part of economic activities, including passenger air transport, causing the cancellation of flights, which translates into a case of contractual breach of the carrier against the passenger. In order to address what response is followed by our legislation against a cancellation due to a force majeure –assuming that the pandemic by COVID-19 is one–, this paper pretends, first of all, resolve the issue regarding the regulations applicable to the air transport contract. Later, the general hypotheses of non-performance of the air transport contract by non-execution of the trip in the agreed terms, and what rights does the passenger have against said non-compliance. Next, the options of the passenger facing a flight canceled by force majeure, and the effects that the latter produces in the contract are discussed. Finally, are analyzed the duties and obligations of the air carrier once the activity has been reactivated, and the liability that it bears for an eventual contagion.
-
FUNDAMENTALS OF GERMAN MEDICAL LIABILITY LAW IN THE FIELD OF AESTHETIC SURGERY
The German medical liability law makes a distinction between the responsibility for treatment mistakes and responsibility for lack of information. Interventions in aesthetic surgery is, as a rule, a medical practice when the physician is below the standard in force in the respective special field of aesthetic plastic surgery. However, in the case of lack of information liability (tort) is based on bodily injury, according to the jurisdiction of German courts is inherent in any medical intervention in body or health status of the patient. However, bodily injury is not considered unlawful if the patient, after having been duly informed, has given valid consent (informed consent). Informed consent, which the treating party should give evidence at trial, can justify the bodily injury. In the aesthetic operations it is of practical importance, above all, the responsibility for insufficient information on the risks of the respective intervention. If aesthetic surgery, as no medical indication occurs often, the requirements for patient information are particularly stringent. In this sense, the jurisdiction requires a extensive, intense and sometimes “thoughtless” information about imminent risks, in the case of offset to some extent the purely “aesthetic indication” by the qualified patient consent after extensive information (intensely informed consent ). If it is found that the information was insufficient, doctors and hospitals may be liable for damages and ordered to pay compensation for personal injury.