Search Results
Search Results
-
SECURITY AND LEGAL CERTAINTY: RELEVANCE AND FUNCTIONS OF THE FOUNDATION OF THE PRESCRIPTION WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO THE SOLUTION OF A DIFFICULT CASE
Legal certainty accomplishes (among others) the function of being a general principle of our legal system, assuming a fundamental role in resolving so-called “difficult” cases. Since we start from the premise that difficult cases must be resolved considering the values and principles that support the civil institution involved, all those cases related to the statute of limitations must be interpreted in accordance with this general principle of law –and legal value– which undoubtedly serves it as a base. Faced with the particular and insistent question of whether the interruption of the statute of limitations requires the mere presentation of the claim or the legal notification of the same within the term, it is this principle the one that offers good reasons to opt for the second option.
-
LEGAL EVIDENCE AND THE SEARCH OF TRUTH: IS IT POSSIBLE TO INTERPRET THE PROBATORY RULES OF THE CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE ACCORDING TO A PRO VERITATIS PRINCIPLE?
This paper addresses the existing tension between the system of legal or weighted evidence currently in force in the Chilean Civil Procedure Code and the pursuit of truth as the primary goal of the probatory stage. In the absence of a civil procedure reform capable of closing the gap between traditional normative structures and contemporary epistemic demands, it proposes an interpretation of probatory rules in accordance with the proposed pro veritatis principle. Through a historical, dogmatic and normative analysis, it is sustained that many of these rules maintain, to varying degrees, an epistemic orientation that justifies their reinterpretation. In that sense, a re-reading of such rules is proposed, aimed at mitigating their most restrictive effects while strengthening the justice of the verdict based on a reasonably proven factic truth. -
THE PRINCIPLE OF PROPORTIONALITY IN PRIVATE LAW: A GENERAL APPROACH AND A PARTICULARIZATION FROM A CONSUMER PROTECTION PERSPECTIVE
The principle of proportionality, rooted in ideals of balance and reasonableness, is challenged at the legal level given its equivocal formulation. In public law, it is generally referred to as limiting the State’s discretion and protecting the rights of individuals through a threefold examination of adequacy, necessity, and proportionality in a strict sense. Such an analysis cannot be simply transferred to private law, either because it could end up eroding the logic of private autonomy, or because relations between private individuals cannot be qualified by the extent to which public policies affect fundamental rights. On the contrary, an evaluative weighing of the rights assigned to each party must be carried out, whether this exercise is done ex ante by the legislator, or ex post by the court. Hence, it is proposed that, unless there is an express or implicit redirection to the constitutional meaning of the principle, the balance between the rights of individuals must be observed in the light of criteria that are proper to private law, such as accepted good behavior (boni mores) and good faith. For these purposes, it is also postulated that in consumer law only a particularization of these rules can be observed, but this does not detract from the fact that their basis can be observed in other private law relationships, where there is a weakness of one of the parties, so that the principle of proportionality, based on ideas from the private law sphere, also serves as a corrective element.
-
The implications of the integrating function of good faith with respect to the obligation to deliver in the contract of sale: subversion, restriction and warranty
In light of an obiter dictum issued by the Supreme Court regarding the scope of the seller’s obligation to deliver, this work seeks to determine the legal implications of integrating, through the principle of good faith under Article 1546 of the Civil Code, the obligation to transfer ownership in the contract of sale. The central thesis is that such integration, as proposed by the Court, subverts the general rule concerning the scope of the seller’s obligation, restricts the regime of eviction, and transforms the obligation to deliver into one of warranty.
-
THE PRINCIPLE OF NON-ARBITRARY DISCRIMINATION AS A LIMIT TO CONTRACTUAL FREEDOM IN COMMON CONTRACT LAW: FORMULATION FROM CHILEAN LAW
This article aims to examine the principle of non-arbitrary discrimination in Chilean common contract law, based on the regulation that this principle has achieved in European law, examining its justification and its possible alternatives for incorporation into our legal system. To this end, it is proposed to conceive it as a consequence of the constitutionalization of private law; it admits that it is a manifestation of human dignity applicable to every individual and, finally, to outline it as a limit to the freedom of contract, opting for this last alternative based on certain rules contained in Chilean contract law that allow it to be understood as such.
-
ABOUT THE OBLIGATIONS ARISING FROM MARRIAGE IN ECUADOR: DO THEY ACTUALLY HAVE A CONTRACTUAL SOURCE?
While the Ecuadorian Constitution and the Identity and Civil Data Organic Law define marriage as a union, the Ecuadorian Civil Code labels it as a solemn contract. Irrespective of the nomenclature used by the constituent assembly and the legislator, we aim to deepen in the analysis of the allegedly contractual character of marriage at the sight of the theory of obligations. We conclude that, although marriage might have similarities with the notion of directed contract, it is not actually so, as the source of its obligations is not contractual but legal. Marriage is a legal transaction that merely modifies a person’s civil status, and it is only as a consequence of the new status that the spouses acquire obligations directly from the law. Finally, the question arises as to whether marriage is moving towards a regime that allows the parties, by maximizing the principle of autonomy of the will, to configure the union with greater freedom.