Search Results
Search Results
-
THE PRICE OF DECLARING THAT THE PRICE HAS BEEN PAID (ART. 1876 OF THE CIVIL CODE)
This commentary analyses a recent decision which held that, if the parties at the sale declare that the price has been paid, the seller will not be able to prove that he did not really receive the price. The decision relies on the wording “no proof will be admitted against this” of art. 1876, which is deemed applicable to the relationship between the parties inasmuch as it would bear witness to the evidentiary value of public instruments laid down in art. 1700. The commentary criticises this decision, since art. 1876 grants certain consequences to the clause that the price has been paid only regarding third parties, as can be seen not only in the wording of this article, but also in the sources which inspired it. The commentary also criticises the evidentiary value which the decision grants to public instruments, as well as the practical consequences which this brings along for everyday commercial practice.
-
THE SCOPE OF APPLICATION OF THE VIENNA CONVENTION ON THE INTERNATIONAL SALE OF GOODS AND ITS INTEGRATION BY THE CHILEAN PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW
This article analyzes some of the most controversial issues that have arisen before Chilean Courts with regard to the scope of application of the CISG and the filling of its gaps (in the absence of general principles) through the application of Chilean choice-of-law rules. The article reviews the decisions of Chilean Courts on the territorial and material scope of application of the CISG; the law applicable to fill its gaps, including the law applicable to agency, limitation periods, property of the goods, burden of proof and the right to withhold performance; as well as the possibility of opting out of the CISG and the effects of the article 96 reservation made by Chile.
-
LIABILITY AS A FORM OF PRIVATE IMPLEMENTATION OF COMPETITION LAW
This article tackles private antitrust enforcement, focusing on one of its concrete expressions: tort liability, in particular between rivals. Using elements of foreign and Chilean law, this article shows that tort liability makes a limited contribution to the deterrence and punishment of anticompetitive conduct. First, antitrust infringements impair mainly consumers and markets as a whole, whilst tort liability is esentially an instrument of compensation for the harm that those acts inflict on individual and identifiable victims, like competitors. Secondly, the complex proof of harm and causation significantly restricts the chance of obtaining redress, thus diminishing the effectiveness of tort liability as a deterrent to anticompetitive behaviour.
-
UNFAIR COMPETITION BY FAULT
The article examines the unlawfulness in acts of unfair competition, pro- vided as a hypothesis of non-contractual civil liability in Law No. 20.169, which regulates unfair competition. Refuting an interpretation made by national scholars and courts, which states that such illicit requires proof of a fraudulent behavior, the article argues how the text of this law, the reliable history of its establishment, its systematic interpretation with others normative bodies (in particular, with the consumer protection that underlies as a legitimate interest expressly in this special law), the consideration of certain comparative experience and, even, a recent jurisprudence of the Supreme Court, allow to sustain in a well-founded manner that a conduct of unfair competition that infringes the ordinary diligence (slight fault) configures that illicit and gives rise to the exercise of the actions that this law establishes.