Search Results
Search Results
-
Nulity of abuse clauses in reservations, promises of sale and purchase signed by consumers of homes marketed in green
This work analyzes the sentence handed down in Sernac against Socovesa S.A., and another (2020) that pronounces on a claim derived for the defense of the collective interest of consumers by virtue of the special procedure established in article 53 of Title IV of the LPDC. The action is based on the different abusive clauses that the defendants maintain in the adhesion contracts that they usually enter into with consumers during the process of buying a house using the so-called green modality; These are the reserve for the home purchase operation, the contract of the promise of sale and the contract of sale with a mutual mortgage. The study focuses specifically on the claims related to the declaration of nullity of certain clauses that were rejected in the judgment of the first instance that was confirmed by the Court of Appeals of Santiago. Consequently, it reflects on the nature of reservations as an adhesion contract, on the interpretation of article 138 bis of the LGUC in the light of consumer rights and also, on the object of the clauses of accordance.
-
Contractual penalty for the breach of the promissory sale of a real state
This commentary analyses a recent decision which declared that a preliminary agreement regarding the sale of an apartment was null and void, since it did not fulfil the requirements of a promissory contract. The court also rejected the sellers’ claim of liquidated damages for CLP $ 40 000 000 on account that it would cause an unjust enrichment. Special attention is drawn both to the features of the contract and to the available mechanisms that allow the moderation of the liquidated damages, which enable a more balanced solution to the one reached by the court.
-
DUSTING OFF THE CIVIL CODE. ABOUT SERNAC’S EXECUTIVE RESOLUTION ON THE INCORPORATION OF DELIVERY DATES OF REAL ESTATE PROJECTS IN OMMUNICATIONS PRIOR TO THE SIGNING OF PURCHASE AND SALE PROMISES
Sernac’s Executive Resolution No. 277, issued on April 21, 2025, addresses the inclusion of delivery dates for real estate projects in communications prior to the signing of preliminary sales agreements. This article offers acritical analysis of the interpretative ruling, highlighting both its strengths and its conceptual ambiguities and normative limitations. It examines the legal nature of SERNAC’s circulars and rulings, their limited normative scope and legal effects, as well as the contractual consequences of breaching preliminary real estate agreements. The discussion also considers the role of Chilean civil law and, in particular, the application of Article 1554 of the Civil Code in promises subject to indeterminate conditions. The article concludes that, although the ruling reinforces certain valuable consumer protection elements, Sernac has missed a meaningful opportunity to clarify –more precisely and with greater technical rigour– the scope of real estate suppliers’ obligations.
-
FORFEITURE CLAUSES AS A MANIFESTATION OF A PARTY’S POWER TO TERMINATE A CONTRACT
The treatment afforded to resolutory clauses by Chilean legislation is limited to their express incorporation into forfeiture clauses inherent in purchase and sale agreements. Such little regulation, coupled with the limited use spared to them by Chilean legal scholars, much like the codifier did, trans- lates into a narrow application to cases of contract non-performance.
That is why, by resorting to such historical background, books of au- thority and case law as may be relevant, this paper aims to determine the legal nature of forfeiture clauses and how they operate in order to better their use as a contractual remedy in the interest of unpaid creditors.