Search Results
Search Results
-
THE RECEPTION OF THE THEORY OF UNFORESEEABILITY IN CHILEAN LAW
This commentary analyzes a ruling by the Court of Appeals of Santiago, where the theory of unforeseeability is applied ex officio. This is a novel issue that contradicts the majority case law due to the exceptional nature of this doctrine. If such judicial practice were to continue, legal certainty could be affected, and, consequently, the binding force of contracts as a general rule. The text develops arguments that refute the absolute nature of the binding force of contracts and the impracticability of unforeseeability whenever the parties request its application. It concludes by discussing how judicial activity in applying this theory ex officio could pose a threat to legal certainty.
-
Related parties’ credits included in a mercantile current account and faithfulness of financial statements. Comment of the Supreme Court’s judgement of July 31, 2020, N. 29.982-2019
The paper analyzes a Supreme Court’s judgement which confirmed, with a reduction, the fines imposed on managers of a public corporation by the former SVS. The firm reported in the financial statements some long-term credits, which debtors where related companies. It did not take steps to collect them in a considerable period of time, on the grounds that they had been included into a mercantile current account with few movements. The supervisor reclassified the credits as long-term, and concluded that the financial statements contained false information. An analysis validates critically this judicial decision, and offers an alternative basis for it, built on the content of the commercial current account contract.
-
JUDICIAL CONFESSION AND BURDEN OF PROOF IN LAW 20.009, WHICH LIMITS THE LIABILITY OF PAYMENT METHODS PROVIDERS AND USERS
This paper analyzes the judgment issued by the Illustrious Court of Appeals of Santiago on May 6, 2025, in case number 2737-2022, originating in the Second Local Police Court of Las Condes, referring to the determination of the liability of payment method providers in relation to possible fraud contemplated in Law 20.009.
-
Shares sell agree d by an apparent director of a non-profit corporation
The paper analyzes a judgment of the Court of Appeals of Antofagasta that seller, a non-profit corporation, acted through directors whose election was later annulled in an electoral proceeding. The corporation, together with one of its members, argued that the contract lacked the will of the seller, and that its object was unlawful, because it violated a judicial prohibition to agree contract on the shares, which, however, at the time of the lawsuit had been revoked. The analysis presented in this commentary critically supports that judicial decision, based on the treatment corresponding to the acts entered by apparent directors and the scope of the nullity that derives from the violation of a judicial prohibition to enter into acts and contracts.
-
-
THE COURT’S DETACHMENT AS A LIMIT TO THE EXERCISE OF JUDICIAL POWER
In the present paper, the judgment issued by the Supreme Court on April 30, 2026, in case docket No. 1608-2023, is analyzed with respect to the scope of the court’s loss of jurisdiction and its consequences for the functional competence of the Court of Appeals when hearing an appeal.