Search Results
Search Results
-
Liability to injury to human rights: need for express constitucional recognition? a review from the perspective of damage repair in the tort law
In the midst of the debate regarding the new Chilean Constitution, this paper goes through the consequences of an eventual incorporation of a norm of constitutional rank in our law that, to a greater or lesser extent, establishes the duty of reparation in the event of a violation of human rights, similar to other Latin American Constitutions; in particular we will analyze the topic of damage repair. The reason behind looking through the different modes that damage repairing for human rights violation takes, is to demonstrate that the law of liability and the standards of human rights law can complement each other, especially in the case that the state or its agents are the culprits of those violations.
-
THE PRINCIPLE OF PROPORTIONALITY IN PRIVATE LAW: A GENERAL APPROACH AND A PARTICULARIZATION FROM A CONSUMER PROTECTION PERSPECTIVE
The principle of proportionality, rooted in ideals of balance and reasonableness, is challenged at the legal level given its equivocal formulation. In public law, it is generally referred to as limiting the State’s discretion and protecting the rights of individuals through a threefold examination of adequacy, necessity, and proportionality in a strict sense. Such an analysis cannot be simply transferred to private law, either because it could end up eroding the logic of private autonomy, or because relations between private individuals cannot be qualified by the extent to which public policies affect fundamental rights. On the contrary, an evaluative weighing of the rights assigned to each party must be carried out, whether this exercise is done ex ante by the legislator, or ex post by the court. Hence, it is proposed that, unless there is an express or implicit redirection to the constitutional meaning of the principle, the balance between the rights of individuals must be observed in the light of criteria that are proper to private law, such as accepted good behavior (boni mores) and good faith. For these purposes, it is also postulated that in consumer law only a particularization of these rules can be observed, but this does not detract from the fact that their basis can be observed in other private law relationships, where there is a weakness of one of the parties, so that the principle of proportionality, based on ideas from the private law sphere, also serves as a corrective element.
-
LIABILITY OF TOBACCO COMPANIES AND THE ROLE OF THE STATE IN THE PROTECTION OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS. ISSUES RAISED
It is well known that cigarette consume is harmful for health and is also known that health is a human right. As a human Right is established by the Argentine National Constitution and the International Treaties of human Rigths included by the constitutional reform approved in 1994.
Effective enjoyment of this right joins with the protection of consumer, both protected by our Constitution, deserving State guarantee.
It is quite important to discriminate who should take responsability for the damage that this consumption causses not only to smokers but also to pasive smokers.
Then it is necessary to establish the link between them and the tabacco companies: if it is contractual or non contractual liability or there is a third possibility arising from the right of consumption, and in turn consider the responsability that the smoker in public spaces and even private spaces may asume, opposite to those who are forced to inhale tobacco smoke.
Also, to conclude, analize the paradoxical role given to the State who appears as guarantor and at the same time violator of the fumdamental rights committed, becoming actor or defendant in trails concerning this issue.
-
CONTRACTUAL SOLIDARISMO IN FRANCE AND THE CONSTITUCIONALIZATION OF CONTRACTS IN COLOMBIA
Recently, a theoretical discourse that advocates a new reading of the general theory of contracts has taken hold. The theory maintains that in light of moral principles expressed through relatively precise “principles,” judges may employ broad powers in moderating economic relations agreed upon by the parties. The article examines, from the perspective of comparative law, the French and the Colombian cases, examining the different applications of this trend in the two countries. The paper uses an eminently critical approach in seeking to reveal the practical implications behind the scholarly rhetoric.
-
THE CONSEQUENCES OF THE INFRINGEMENT OF MARRIAGE DUTIES DO NOT GIVE RISE TO LIABILITY FOR DAMAGES
In accordance with our rules and jurisprudence, the consequences of the breach of marital duties shall not be compensated, as they are not obligations. Additionally, Law establishes special effects in this case, the protection of fundamental rights of the spouses is opposed to compensation and there are huge difficulties to assess the requirements of civil liability.