Search Results
Search Results
-
Contractual penalty for the breach of the promissory sale of a real state
This commentary analyses a recent decision which declared that a preliminary agreement regarding the sale of an apartment was null and void, since it did not fulfil the requirements of a promissory contract. The court also rejected the sellers’ claim of liquidated damages for CLP $ 40 000 000 on account that it would cause an unjust enrichment. Special attention is drawn both to the features of the contract and to the available mechanisms that allow the moderation of the liquidated damages, which enable a more balanced solution to the one reached by the court.
-
Nulity of abuse clauses in reservations, promises of sale and purchase signed by consumers of homes marketed in green
This work analyzes the sentence handed down in Sernac against Socovesa S.A., and another (2020) that pronounces on a claim derived for the defense of the collective interest of consumers by virtue of the special procedure established in article 53 of Title IV of the LPDC. The action is based on the different abusive clauses that the defendants maintain in the adhesion contracts that they usually enter into with consumers during the process of buying a house using the so-called green modality; These are the reserve for the home purchase operation, the contract of the promise of sale and the contract of sale with a mutual mortgage. The study focuses specifically on the claims related to the declaration of nullity of certain clauses that were rejected in the judgment of the first instance that was confirmed by the Court of Appeals of Santiago. Consequently, it reflects on the nature of reservations as an adhesion contract, on the interpretation of article 138 bis of the LGUC in the light of consumer rights and also, on the object of the clauses of accordance.
-
Abusividad por falta de transparencia, nulidad de cláusulas no incorporadas e improcedencia de responsabilidad infraccional. 17° Juzgado de Letras en lo Civil de Santiago, 27 de enero de 2017, rol n.° 15092-2015. Corte de Apelaciones de Santiago, 7 de septiembre de 2018, rol n.° 8261-2017. Corte Suprema, 27 de diciembre de 2019, rol n.° 114-20191
A fin de concretar la venta de unidades de diversos proyectos inmobiliarios, Constructora Santa Beatriz S.A., a partir de 2002, desarrolló un modelo de contratación que, desde la perspectiva de cada consumidor interesado, comprendía la celebración de tres contratos diferentes: un contrato de reserva, uno de promesa de compraventa y uno de compraventa. De acuerdo con el modelo mencionado, el “proceso de compraventa de un departamento en modalidad verde” comenzaba por la celebración de un contrato de reserva, en cuya virtud el consumidor vinculado debía entregar en el mismo acto una suma de diez unidades de fomento, debiendo la inmobiliaria abstenerse de ofrecer en el mercado el departamento reservado por un plazo de quince días corridos. Una vez realizada la reserva y dentro de los quince días siguientes, el consumidor podía optar por desistirse del proceso de compra –siéndole restituidas las respectivas diez unidades de fomento–, o persistir en el mismo. En este último caso, la inmobiliaria lo citaba para la suscripción de un contrato de promesa, obligándose el consumidor a celebrar la compraventa prometida dentro del plazo establecido en la promesa, siempre que se hubieran cumplido las condiciones impuestas por la inmobiliaria. (...)
-
The business behind death. Park cemeteries as non-traditional financial suppliers
This article presents a commentary about the decisión of the 3rd Local Police Court of Maipú, confirmed by the Supreme Court, in which, after analyzing various elements of the promise of sale that the consumer contracted with a cemetery, it was determined that the business was, actually, similar to a leasing, and included the provision of a financial product, being possible to apply rules of Law No. 18.010 in conjunction with Law No. 19.496.
Although this qualification allows greater protection to the consumer against what may be considered a hidden financial product, the concept of “direct credit” allows a better explanation of the contract, allowing to understand that the operation carried out is a money loan, but it’s granted in a fictional way to the consumer.
-