Search Results
Search Results
-
Related parties’ credits included in a mercantile current account and faithfulness of financial statements. Comment of the Supreme Court’s judgement of July 31, 2020, N. 29.982-2019
The paper analyzes a Supreme Court’s judgement which confirmed, with a reduction, the fines imposed on managers of a public corporation by the former SVS. The firm reported in the financial statements some long-term credits, which debtors where related companies. It did not take steps to collect them in a considerable period of time, on the grounds that they had been included into a mercantile current account with few movements. The supervisor reclassified the credits as long-term, and concluded that the financial statements contained false information. An analysis validates critically this judicial decision, and offers an alternative basis for it, built on the content of the commercial current account contract.
-
SETTLEMENT OF THE JUDGMENT GIVEN IN A CLASS PROCEDURE AND ALTERNATIVES FOR THE REPAIR OF INDETERMINATE CONSUMERS
This paper analyzes the rule pronounced by the Court of Appeals of Santiago on September 7, 2023, in case No. 5740-2021, titled “Servicio Nacional del Consumidor con Farmacias Cruz Verde y otras”, referring to the payment of damages suffered by consumers in the “Farmacias Case”, which condemned Farmacias Cruz Verde, Salcobrand and Fasa for collusion and which resulted in a collective proceeding ordering the payment of the corresponding indemnities to consumers. This proceeding ended with an agreement between SERNAC and Farmacias Cruz Verde and Salcobrand, excluding Fasa, which decided to continue with the proceeding by means of an appeal.
-
THE DECEIVED BUYER, THE FRAUDS TER’S BANK AND THE LIMITS OF THE CLAIM FOR PROFITS FOR SOMEONE ELSE’S FRAUD
This commentary analyses a decision which narrows down the scope of the claim for profits derived from someone else’s fraud. This offers a clear contrast against the backdrop of recent case law, which established very general requirements for such claims. The decision granted special attention to the notion of “profit” of articles 1458 and 2316 of the CC. Accordingly, this commentary reviews the scope of this provisions based on their historical origin and practical outcomes. Additionally, the commentary critically approaches the relationship between the aforementioned articles and the claims that can be brought by those who suffered the consequences of the fraud.
-
ON THE OPP ORTUNITY TO CLAIM THE ABANDONMENT OF THE PROCEDURE: THE CRITERION OF THE THIRD CHAMBER OF THE SUPREME COURT
Classic doctrine and jurisprudence understand that the abandonment of the procedure has no time limit for its filing, as long as an enforceable judgment has not been ruled on. Thus, the general rule on the time limit for the filing of incidents, set out in Article 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure, is not applicable to it. However, a series of rulings handed down by the Third Chamber of the Supreme Court have changed this approach. Based on an argumentative evolution, which began with an argument of procedural good faith, this Chamber has considered that the rule of article 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure is applicable to the incident of abandonment of the procedure. The aim of this paper is to show this evolution and to give an account of the problems of interpretation that can arise when considering this rule applicable.
-
ASSESSMENT OF THE EXPERTISE AND INFRINGEMENT OF THE LAWS REGULATORY OF THE EVENT
This paper analyzes the sentence pronounced by the Supreme Court, dated March 22, 2023, in case number 144.044-2020, titled “SQM Salar S.A. against the Chilean Treasury”, referring to the granting of a mining easement requested by the plaintiff with respect to twelve hectares, for fifty years. The Supreme Court, in a cassation ruling on the merits, annuls the final sentence handed down by the Antofagasta Court of Appeals and instead confirms the one pronounced in the first instance.
-